Service Areas
About Colleen Teifer
OTHER LANGUAGES
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Credentials
LICENSE
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Ocean Isle Beach, NC
2026
TOP AGENT
Sunset Beach, NC
2026
TOP AGENT
Calabash, NC
Available Listings View All



View All Listings2026
Ocean Isle Beach, NC
2026
Sunset Beach, NC
2026
Calabash, NC



View All ListingsColleen was one other best realtor we have ever had after buying and selling houses for over 45 years.She was very knowledgeable and made the whole experience stress free with no problems. I would recommend her 100%
Results oriented broker with excellent market knowledge. Colleen is a top performing broker with market knowledge and contacts to get the job done. It is evident that Colleen enjoys her profession and helping customers sell and find a home. Colleen priced our home correctly for the market which helped it sell faster. She also has extensive contacts for contractors that were able to complete the small jobs needed after the inspection. If you're looking for a dedicated professional with a great personality, look no further.
Colleen not only did an excellent job in listing and selling our townhouse but her knowledge of the local market and helping us find professionals to address any outstanding issues with our home went above and beyond what we had experienced in the past.
Exceptional Experience. We have used Colleen multiple times and every experience has been greet. Colleen is very knowledgeable of the area and will not misguide you. Colleen listens and communicates clearly, she takes the time to listen to your preferences. Colleen is very personable and works hard to deliver for you, just a great person to be around and an excellent choice for all your real estate needs.
Colleen was wonderful to work with. She was honest and realistic in helping us arrive at the listing price so we could get maximum value and yet have it sold in as short a time as possible. Her photographer took great pictures of both the interior and exterior which she incorporated into a beautiful brochure . It was displayed on the sign in the front yard so prospective buyers could decide whether to ask for a showing. She was diligent is booking showings and giving us adequate time of them so we could present the house at its best. She was easy to work with. Her professionality and experience made selling our home as stress free as possible. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She gives 100% in everything she does
Trusted, Knowledgeable, and Incredibly Helpful. In a market with plenty of listings but very few homes that truly met my specific criteria at my price point, Colleen was outstanding. Since this was a long-distance move, I especially appreciated how she helped me understand the community and guided me toward areas where the lifestyle I was looking for really made sense. She negotiated effectively on my behalf, made sure every detail was in order for closing, and even made the utility transfers incredibly simple. Colleen was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely had my best interests in mind throughout the process. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home. Given her attention to detail, I can't imagine it being any different with any real estate transaction.
Excellent Support! My wife and I moved from Maryland and relocated to Ocean Isle Beach NC. Colleen was referred to us as the best to work with. Colleen got to know us and our needs. She found several excellent properties for us that exceeded our expectations. We bought a wonderful new home and are so thankful to her! She took care of so many details with our move and truly made it much easier and a smooth process. I highly recommend her as your realtor!
Exceptional Realtor Who Goes Above and BeyondaEUR"Truly the Best in NC Coastal Area. Working with Colleen has been the best real estate experience weve had in over 25 years. She took the time to truly understand me, my family, and what we were looking for in a home. Her goal was never just to help us buy a house aEUR" she wanted us to love where we landed and feel completely confident in our decision. Her knowledge of the North Carolina coastal area is extraordinary. Colleen gave us a thoughtful, detailed overview of the region, introduced us to neighborhoods that aligned with our lifestyle, and helped us understand the nuances of each coastal community. She knew which areas would fit our needs, which areas were up-and-coming, and how each location would feel day-to-day - helping us find the right fit for our family. Because we were six hours away, we relied heavily on her guidance, and she went above and beyond. She visited homes on our behalf, sent thorough videos, and provided honest, insightful feedback so we never felt distant from the process. Her dedication, communication, and genuine care made everything smooth and stress-free. I truly cant say enough about her. Her expertise in the NC coastal market and her commitment to her clients truly set her apart.
Highly-Recommended Knowledgeable Professional . Colleen has extensive knowledge of the area and neighborhoods, which we appreciated as we planned our move from out of state. She was thorough in her preparation to review properties within our parameters, mapped out the properties for showings, and maximized our schedule. She was flexible, even giving up some of her personal time, when we needed to see a property again on short notice. When the time came to do so, she provided all the information we needed to make an informed offer to get us the best possible deal on our new home. But she didn't stop there - she was excellent in her communication from offer to to closing, helping us with getting the inspection, having work done (at the expense of the seller) to correct some things found on the inspection, and so much more. She was always quick to respond to our questions, very pleasant to work with, and so very helpful. She really made our experience a breeze - even from 500 miles away! We highly recommend Colleen for your buying or selling needs - you won't be disappointed!
Colleen is the best in Brunswick County! We had the pleasure of working with Colleen when we purchased our home and then again when it was time to sell. Her professionalism and local market knowledge is unparalleled, from professional photos, online marketing and setting the right price for our home to streamlining the selling process. We were able to sell our house quickly and profitably in a slow resale market due to her guidance. She is the best in Brunswick County!
We met with Colleen looking to relocate from NY. We gave her our wish list. She listened!! She immediately found properties geared to our desires & Colleen met with us to show us around to what we were looking for! We found our forever home thanks to her!!!!! Colleen helped us every step of the way!!! I highly recommend her for her knowledge, professionalism & her approachable/very friendly manner!
Colleen was wonderful during the entire process of sale of our home. It took us a while due to market and timing of listing but she got it done!! Colleen was always reachable at all hours of every day if I had questions or concerns. She also put me in touch with the best folks to take care of minor things prior to closing. Colleen also kept an eye on our home while we were out of town. When storms rolled thru, she would go by to ensure our home was safe and clear of any debris. During the many offers, she helped guide us to the right buyer for our home. I had great neighbors so that was really important to us Lots more praises for Colleen but trying not to write a book! LOL
We decided to relocate to the Brunswick County Beaches and used Colleen. It was a wonderful experience. She is the only realtor to reach out with a great packet of information. We had specific requirements for a location and amenities and Colleen showed us all places that matched that list. The market was very hot at the time so we decided to buy a golf course lot and build. She helped us find a lot with little chance of flooding; she knew all the lots on the market from memory. She also put us in touch with a lender and builder who she recommended and trusted from prior experience. We are now in our house and love it and the community we chose. I would highly recommend Colleen.
We recently purchased a home in Bolivia, NC. Colleen Teifer of Silver Coast Properties was our realtor. She is extremely good at the whole realtor business. We could not have made it through the process of looking for, finding, making an offer on, finding a mortgage for, finding insurance for, finding a NC lawyer to help us with the purchase of, or getting hooked up with the common utility companies for the house we wanted. We were the kind of home buyers that were very picky about what we wanted and we took several years to decide that we finally had the house we wanted. Colleen patiently showed us house after house only to have us leave NC without buying any of the houses we saw. We visited southern NC several times over three years and she was always willing to take us to see more houses. She did her homework and showed us houses that matched what we told her we wanted to see. She was able to fill in most of the holes in the information on the homes that we needed to know, even if the information was not on the papers prepared for prospective buyers. When we finally decided to make an offer on a house, Colleen walked us through that process. We decided what we wanted to offer for the house and Colleen did all the work for us after that. When the sellers accepted our offer, Colleen stayed with us and connected us with all of the people and businesses we needed to make that purchase happen. Colleen was there with us to resolve any difficulties we had with those people and companies. If you're trying to decide if you want to buy are you're serious about finding a new home in the south NC area, you couldn't ask for a better realtor than Colleen Teifer of Silver Coast Properties.
We looked for a place at Sunset and OIB for close to two years. Colleen showed us +75 properties over that time period. We would come down usually on a day trip and see 5-7 properties at a time. Colleen was able to flawlessly arrange all of the requested visits. Colleen was punctual, professional and very knowledgable. My wife and I highly recommend Colleen.
Colleen was an immense help in assisting my partner and I as we relocated to the Sunset Beach area and purchased a home. She was patient with our endless questions, responsive with communications, and even made herself available after closing to make sure our transition went smoothly. I would highly recommend her as an established realtor in the area who knows the market and values the comfort and success of her clients through every stage of the process.
You cannot go wrong when using Colleen Teifer as your Realtor. We have had the pleasure of using her three times. Twice when we purchased and once when we sold our home. When we listed our home with Colleen, she sold it the same day. Her listings stand apart from others. The attention to detail she put into the write-up of our home was amazing. The professional photographer she used to take photos was fantastic. The photos were magazine quality. It took us a long time to find the perfect home to purchase and Colleen was so patient and understanding. She did not rush us in anyway. She was there for us throughout the entire process. She is extremely knowledgeable and is very familiar with the area. We recommend her to all our friends. You are in the best hands when you use Colleen.
Colleen is exceptional. We met her by chance as we were looking to move from the Midwest to North Carolina. We were interested in a specific area and impressed with Colleens knowledge. We were also impressed with the amount of data we had about the market. Colleen was an easy choice, and we are glad we chose her. Colleen was ALWAYS available for home tours. Since we were out of state, Colleen conducted numerous virtual house tours for us and provided great insight on houses, builders, etc. She was very responsive and always professional. Ultimately, we purchased a great home in our neighborhood built by one of the top builders in the state. Colleen did an incredible amount of information gathering throughout the process, and kept us well informed throughout the process. She will look out for you and keep your best interest in mind. Colleen will work with you to make your desires a reality. She is also very well-versed in dealing with other real estate agents. When there were disagreements about certain verbiage in documents, Colleen was patient and worked through the entire process without breaking a sweat. Her cool, calm mindset kept our anxiety low and gave us confidence she would get the job doneaEUR"and she did! Her promptness, market knowledge, strategic mindset, kindness, and great energy made a potentially chaotic purchase process simple. We have already recommended her to two of our good friends. If you are looking to buy, we highly recommend Colleen. Dont hesitate to give her a call.
Colleen was a consummate professional. From helping my husband and I to find the right community that fits "us" to guiding us through the closing process and now to the building process. Colleen really listened to us and imparted her knowledge and insight in a way that was so beneficial and welcoming considering we did not know the area at all. Colleen was always quick to respond to our several concerns and questions, whether it was via text or email.
Colleen was awesome! We didnt have much experience in the area and she steered us to the perfect spot. She knew the area so well and we trusted her to give us her honest opinion. Shes a great communicator, professional, and friendly. We can honestly give her our highest recommendationaEUR| Thanks Colleen!!!
Colleen was the best. We were not very familiar with the area so she helped us decide where we wanted to be and went above and beyond to help us get a place in our dream location. Even when we didnt get the 1st couple we bid on she kept meeting us even when she was recovering from surgery. We cannot express how grateful we are for Colleen.
Even though our path went in a different direction we wanted to share our experience with Silver Coast Properties,Ocean Isle Beach,N.C. agent Colleen Teifer.From her first call reaching out to us to the hours she spent with us.She did so much preparation before we started each day on our journeys.Her knowledge of each area was so helpful.Hearing us when we would say our likes and dislikes.Always respected the perimeters we set for our price range.we felt so comfortable with her and never pressured. She is the perfect blend of what a professional realtor should be. We were actually sad to not move forward and purchase a home under her guidance. We will highly recommend her to anyone we know that will be interested in these areas. THANK YOU FOR ALL YOU DID, Ron & Judy Hickerson
Colleen did a tremendous job in helping us prepare and then sell my father's home in Sea Trail. My brother and I both live out of state, so managing the preparation of his house and then listing it was going to be a big undertaking for us. I selected Colleen based on the volume of transactions she completed in prior years, which proved to be a good decision. Colleen helped connect us to the right vendors to inspect, make repairs and clean up the house prior to listing. Her contractors were extremely capable, responsive and reasonably priced. I believe this house sold quickly because of Colleen's direction on what needed to be addressed and how. The closing process itself was incredibly smooth. I would highly recommend Colleen as a listing agent.
We loved working with Colleen Teifer and would HIGHLY recommend her to our family, friends or anyone looking for a realtor. We recently relocated from New Jersey to North Carolina. We were very concerned about purchasing a home out of state. We knew we wanted to be near the coast but didnt know much about the area, or the many communities, outside of what we would read while doing research online. We had no family or friends in the area that we could depend on for advice and suggestions. Colleen was that person for us!! She took the time to understand our likes & dislikes and really got to know us, what we were looking for and what would be best for our family. Although Colleen was in NC and we were in NJ it never was an issue. She always made herself available for a phone call. She was always very responsive via text or email. She sent us new listings as they would come up and would go above and beyond even aEURoephysicallyaEUR? driving over to a house to check it out for us or set up an appt to do a walk thru with us on the phone or for us. Additionally, since she is so experienced, she would point out subtle things that we would have missed but were really important for our decision process. Things such as building concerns, water level concerns and many others. She even told us, very politely, that she wouldnt sell us a home in a particular community because of the problems theyve had with flooding and she knew that was a major concern of ours. She could have very easily sold us a home there but thats not Colleen. She does everything with integrity!! Several times we took weekend trips to tour communities and Colleen made it extremely easy. She would always create an itinerary of communities and homes to tour. All we had to do was was show up where she told us to meet her and she took care of everything else and it always went smoothly. She made the whole process very easy and alot less nerve wracking than I ever thought it would be.Colleen went above and beyond to help us during every stage of the process. Another huge perk about Colleen is that she has relationships with and works with local real estate lawyers and banks that were able to support us during what's normally a very stressful mortgage & closing process. Colleen is professional, dedicated, reliable, detail oriented, has great communication skills and does everything with integrity. She is also a very kind, friendly, patient and conscientious person. We consider ourselves extremely lucky and blessed to have had Colleen as our Realtor!! We will eternally be grateful that she helped us find our beautiful home and we no longer consider her our realtor but our friend.
We moved from Virginia to Ocean Isle Beach in 2023 and Colleen was the absolute perfect fit for our need(s). She took the time to get to know us personally, learned our likes/dislikes through active listening, and quickly gained an understanding of what we were looking for in our next home (the must haves versus nice-to-haves). Colleen's detailed knowledge of the surrounding area(s) and her thorough understanding of all the builders proved invaluable as she provided honest/forthright input and offered thoughts/questions we hadn't previously considered in our decision-making process. When we had questions or thoughts, Colleen was always available, any time day or night. She was immediately responsive and able to answer our question(s) without delay. At a point where you're looking for your forever home, Colleen's knowledge, confidence, and continuous reassurance / support were exactly what we needed. Simply put, she's the absolute best !
Colleen helped us with the purchase of our second home in OIB. She was knowledgeable about new developments and the community. When we finally did settle in on a home, it was reassuring to know she checked in with the builder and addressed our concerns since we could. It be here on a daily basis. Highly recommend Colleen.
Absolutely loved working with Colleen. We fell upon her looking at a home on-line. We were new to the area. Colleen not only knows the area but takes her time to pinpoint the home we were looking for. She did not waste our time looking at just any home and she always kept us in our price range. Colleen is very honest and always a phone call, email or text away. She even went out of her way to take care of some incidentals that she clearly did not have to and still keeps in touch with us to make sure we are taken care of.
Colleen was outstanding as our agent in selling our lot. She was always available to answer our questions and was able to sell our property for top dollar. Shes knowledgeable, friendly and an outstanding real estate agent. I would highly recommend Colleen for all your real estate needs!
Colleen is in many ways the perfect agent: tirelessly working to find answers that we needed, detail oriented enough to match my idealistic concerns, great with people throughout the community and in public office, and she has a knack for anticipating & solutioning situations where our concerns tended to pop-up during the pre-close & closing processes. We were new to the area, but we had ideas for where we thought we 'should be' looking. Colleen patiently listened to us describe our dream, she diligently probed us for the primary must haves, and she confidently directed us throughout the explore process until we found the lot and home that we dreamed about.
Colleen was so good selling our condo in Little River I used her to help me buy a property on Sunset Beach .She was extremely professional and responsive
Colleen has a thorough knowledge of all the surrounding areas and a comprehensive knowledge of each builder and their respective communities. She pays great attention to every detail of the build and the community. She asked all the right questions to ensure that we were comfortable with our decisions in the purchase and build of our home, that we had in-depth understanding of the process and that we were satisfied and happy. She was present at closing and assisted us with following through on all the necessary paperwork, including connecting with all the utility companies. If we had a question or concern, we could contact her any time, any day. Even on a holiday! She responded almost immediately and helped to resolve the issues and answered questions to our satisfaction. We felt greatly supported. She told us that she would be there for us every step the way and she was. We had not one worry. My husband and I have built 4 homes together and never have we worked with someone so dedicated to her profession. She is the best!
Colleen was fantastic! She was very knowledgeable and easy to work with. She got me exactly what I was looking for. Colleen went the extra mile and helped me work everything out to meet my needs. I definitely recommend her for all your real estate needs. I'm from out of town and she accommodated all of those special needs also. She was a joy to work with. If youre looking for a great lady who knows the area give her a call she can help you too!
My husband , Jeff, and I were introduced to Colleen via a friend, whom she also helped find their new home. From the beginning Colleen patiently listened to our needs and wants for a home in the Sunset Beach area. She was very professional, yet listened as a friend would, confirming what we said, answering questions, and making us feel at ease with this big step we were taking. We began emailing and she would check in with us and communicate at our comfort level. She never tried to talk us into or out of anything, and when she showed us our home and we knew it was aEURoethe oneaEUR? Colleen facilitated the sale efficiently and went above and beyond to help us with places to shop, a painter who was able to paint right away, and a mortgage broker. We would highly recommend Colleen to help anyone fill any of their real estate needs!
We were very fortunate to have Colleen as our agent. We met on the phone in early spring, looking to relocate from New York to North Carolina. From our first conversation to actually moving into our home, Colleen went above and beyond looking for the right home for us, with a lot of patience. She was always a phone call away for any questions or concerns we had in looking for a home. She is extremely knowledgeable, straightforward, never pushed us into buying and found us a wonderful home! Thank you for all you have done for us over theses last 6 mons. I had 3 other agents looking for us and Colleen was the most devoted! Thank you! Full service!
From the time of our initial contact with Colleen until closing the entire process worked like a well oiled machine. Her professionalism and upbeat personality gave us confidence in her ability and she proved us correct in our belief we had chosen the right realtor. Colleen kept us informed and was always quick to respond to any of our questions. We have commented many times since our experience with Colleen what a pleasure it was and how fortunate we were to have her sell our home.
Colleen Teifer is without a doubt the best! She helped us in the home buying process every step of the way. She showed us many different communities, helped us narrow down our choices based on what our requirements were and when we decided to go with a new build (something we had no experience with) she guided us through each step. She was patient with all of our questions and, as a matter of fact, she is still answering any questions that we have now as we are living our North Carolina lives! We highly recommend her for her expertise, knowledge and kind demeanor!
Colleen did a great job selling my 1/2 acre residential lot in Carolina Shores North - it was listed and two days later we received an offer and thirty days later we were closing - Thank you Colleen -
Colleen did a tremendous job in helping me sell my home and purchase a new home. She sold my home in one day for full price. While representing both seller and buyer she worked diligently to ensure a smooth closing, while working on my purchase of my new home. One of her greatest strengths is the ability to multitask.She goes above and beyond to deliver the very best service for her clients.
With a big move from New York I needed someone who could handle a big situation and I found her. Colleen helped me every step of the way from finding the perfect spot, to keeping the builders honest. She knows her business through and through and it made the whole process that much smoother. I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a Realtor.
Selling a home is a stressful process. We certainly had the very best agent anyone could ever hope for in Colleen Teifer. She took the stress away and made us feel completely comfortable and at ease with the process. She did everything in a professional and timely manner. We were especially pleased with the way Colleen was quick to answer our questions and respond to our needs. If we had remained in the area, we have no doubt that Colleen would have become our good friend because her personality was so pleasing.We highly recommend Colleen for a realtor whether you are selling or buying. There in no doubt you will be very satisfied with her professionalism and ability ti get the job done!
Colleen is an amazing person! From the first email and then phone call Colleen was attentive, professional and in our court every step of the way! She listened to us and remembered what our needs were , never steering us in a different direction, always on point. We are so appreciative to her for helping us make our goals and dreams come true with our relocation plans. You will not be disappointed if you reach out to Colleen when you are ready to find your new home! Thank you Colleen!!
Buying a house from another state could be very stressful, but Colleen made it easy. Our experience with Colleen was fabulous! She is extremely knowledgeable about the area and explained to us many different communities that would be suitable for us. She always returned our emails, phone calls, and texts promptly, is incredibly attentive, and has excellent communication skills. She made the entire process of buying a house feel under control and comfortable. We are so thankful Colleen was our realtor and we highly recommend her.
Colleen helped us find the perfect new home build on our move to Coastal Carolina. Now we've partnered with Colleen to purchase an investment lot. She is so knowledgeable and a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!
From the first call we received from Colleen to meeting her to selling our condo and buying our new home , we couldnt have been in better hands. Her knowledge and professionalism is amazing. We had no idea what it entailed in selling our condo or buying a new home but couldnt have asked for a better person to help us through this ordeal. We are grateful for her help and making the process so easy. Thank you
There aren't enough stars to rate how high I value Colleen! She was with me every step of the way and got me the best price I could for my home. Colleen is the standard all realtors should strive to reach in customer service. Knowledge, integrity, professionalism, boundless energy and friendliness are just a few terms to describe her. She has found me homes and sold my homes. I only wish I could have brought her with me when I moved to NY. There is no one better to take care of your home buying or selling for you.
We would like to thank Colleen for all of her hard work and effort on our behalf.We can't say enough about her skills and talent , but hope the following will do-She is very hard working focused and organized. She took the time out to know what we did and did not need to make us happy, she was available to help and advise on short notice and always made sure our needs were addressed . Her experience was essential to the success of our home purchase, she was always on top of any topic and was ready for the " next step" due to her experience.She is well connected to home inspectors , pest control company's, lenders, local utility's and a competent and user friendly local settlement company/ attorney. All of these connections saved us time, money and stress.Her focus was on finding us what we wanted and we appreciate it. We would recommend Colleen to anyone who is hope shopping.
When we were thinking about moving to the North Carolina coast from out-of-state, we knew it would be a great adventure, but also potentially problematic. From the time we made our first inquiries about the move to closing, having Colleen Teifer as our realtor was the best decision we could've made. Colleen is not only very professional, but was sincerely attentive to our needs and concerns. We had moved many times, but never out-of-state. There were many things to consider, and she communicated with us long before we made the actual decision to move. During our search for a home and through the entire process through closing, Colleen was always available, went the extra mile and was absolutely indispensable to us. Colleen has an engaging personality and is extremely knowledgeable about real estate and the area. She made everything fall into place. We are so happy that we found her and very highly recommend her to all who need a quality, expert real estate agent.-Linda and Jeff Williams
We've never had such a great experience with a realtor. Nor did we ever expect the efforts made by one individual to go way beyond what you could ever imagine. Professional. Knowledgeable. Never pushy. Gets to know her clients, their personal needs. Does her job so well and makes sure that everything that needs to get done, is done! Don't bother with the rest of the agents out there that are just interested in closing and making a buck. Colleen is hands down, the Realtor you need to work with! Because she works for you! Not for herself!
Colleen was our agent as we made our move from NY to NC. She helped us understand the unique differences between the many different areas and developments we were considering to find the perfect one. I would highly recommend Colleen as she is extremely knowledgeable about the market, has tremendous integrity, and a pleasure to work with!
Colleen was so helpful and knowledgeable in helping us with our real estate needs.She was always quick on answering our questions and actually walked and videoed our new property before we put in our offer. Living in another state and buying property can be hard as it was bought without us actually seeing it in person. Colleen made us feel at ease and we trusted her judgment completely. We highly recommend her!!
Loading recent sales...