Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Kela S.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIEDCay was excellent to work with! He was always available to assist with everything we needed before listing our home and provided excellent referrals for staging, handyman services, movers, and more, making the entire process as simple and stress-free as possible. We received an offer very quickly and were able to close within just a few weeks. His communication, professionalism, and attention to detail gave us confidence throughout the entire process. Thank you, Cay and Team!
Craig R.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay and Carly are a great team. Ive sold and purchased four houses with their help in the past and never hibeen disappointed. I recommend them to anyone needing experience and integrity in buying and selling residential real estate. Our last house was sold quickly and for the price we had hoped to get.
User5585328
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I had the pleasure of working with Carly while buying my dream home! She was professional, attentive, and truly dedicated to helping me find the perfect home. Her drive and determination to get the job done quickly and efficiently was truly impressive. She negotiated with the seller a fair price for my home and answered all my questions quickly, while walking me through the process, as it was my first time buying a home in CA. Her knowledge of the market and real estate was clear and made me feel confident throughout the entire process. I cannot recommend her enough. Anytime anyone asks who I will work with in the future I tell them immediately of my great experience and tell them about Cay and Carly. If you are looking for a reliable, trustworthy, and efficient agent, look no further!
Adaniels040
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Carly has sold 2 of our homes for top market prices. She is the epitome of professional and is exceptionally detail oriented. Her main focus is on her clients and you can trust that she has your best interest at heart. Couple that with her extraordinary market knowledge and vibrant personality and she delivers a pleasant home selling/buying experience. I can wholeheartedly recommend Carly, Cay and the rest of their team without any reservation.
Rybtjc73
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay and his team did a great job for us. They were responsive to all of our questions or concerns in a very timely manner. At first meeting Cay had all comps and demographics for the area to help establish a realistic price for the house. Set up a marketing plan that was very good. Would recommend them to anyone and will use them in the future.
Zuser20200113092203802
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was easy to work with & responsive to my needs i was happy with him & highly recommend his professionalism if i need any future help selling or buying i will call him for sure. Jarlath Dorney
Greg H.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay and team are a pleasure to work with. Very conscientious and detail oriented. They will not give up until you find the home of your dreams. Cay's value really shined once we were in a negotiation and in escrow. He was fully engaged though the entire process. He brought forward many referrals of inspectors, lenders, and contractors so that we could immediately get the improvements started without having to find and vet new relationships. After close of escrow Cay was out many times to ensure his contractor referrals where giving us their full attention. You can count on a fully engaged and dedicated team when working with Cay.It was turnkey service !
Adriborroel
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was a fantastic realtor that assisted us in buying our first home. Being new to the process, Cay was always available to answers any questions or hesitations. In addition, he never made us feel dumb when asking questions. Through the paperwork process, him and his team were very organized and available to view the countless homes we viewed. In this very competitive market, it was great to have Cay in our corner. Cay and Aaron were great to work with!
Douglashbarker0
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was my agent in two real estate transactions relating to my personal residences, the most recent having closed in September 2021. In short, Cay is the best! He is extraordinarily knowledgeable about real estate and real estate transactions. That said, if there was a question for which he did not have the answer, he ALWAYS got me the answer, usually in the same day. He pays attention to all details. He always kept me informed on status and developments, often on a daily basis. Cay makes his clients feel as if each is his only client, though such is far, far from the truth. Cay has a great reputation and very sizable client base. I highly recommend Cay and his team. You will not be disappointed.
User7367672
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED We have been working with Carly for 7 years and 4 home purchases and 2 home sales! Since her dad, Cay, and her husband, Patrick, are both real estate superstars, you get such deep team expertise. They're incredibly knowledgable about the San Diego market but we've purchased homes in Idyllwild and Big Bear with them as well.They are really well-connected in the community as well, they introduced us to our mortgage broker and we were able to refinance all of our homes with him. They also connected us to a 1031 exchange specialist to save on taxes. Selling our home was the easiest experience EVER working with Carly. I only had to go to the home once, she took care of cleaning, repairs, painting, staging, tours, and all else that goes into selling. We sold way above our asking price and were thrilled.When buying our home in the very competitive Poway School District, she was able to get our offer accepted even though there were many other offers at the same price point. We were SO LUCKY to get our forever home in Poway and I know it would not have happened without Carly. Highly recommended!!
Paula B.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay is an experienced, thoughtful and very thorough real estate agent. He was hands on through every step of the sale of our home. Along with making staging recommendations, he was also able to guide us in making minor repairs and adjustments to show our home at its best. He was very familiar with our area and recommended pricing in accordance to real estate trends as they are today. I believe most people would be extremely pleased choosing Cay and his team as their next real estate agent!
Vb4fpbtxms
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay Bonsack and his team worked well with listing and selling our property that included a custom home and ten acres of income-producing agricultural crops. This was not the usual and customary type of property most realtors were used to. Cay met the numerous challenges presented. He learned from us and we learned from him. He advised us along the way and was open to discussing many of the issues present. He honored our preferences as needed. His communication skills were excellent.
GRushing27
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Thanks to Cay, we were able to purchase our home during the peak of the housing market.As the bidding war was so insane, we were specifically looking for a good buyer's agent. Houses sell themselves these days, so it's easy for agents to get good reviews if they are representing sellers more than buyers. Through reviews, we found out Cay helped a lot of buyers to purchase homes, and we are glad we went with him. Although he was also surprised by the sudden competition that was pouring to the rural San Diego area, he helped us to place a strong and a smart offer, and our offer was accepted. We believe it wasn't an offer that can be suggested by an agent unless he/she had a lot of experience. Also, we had a quite a difficult loan officer to work with, yet Cay was calm through the entire process and helped us go through it without panicking. He also sent out handy men behalf of us so we can do minor fixes on our house before we can even move in.He was professional, very easy to reach out to, and responded quickly. We'll recommend Cay to anyone who is looking to purchase in San Diego area.
TaraLopano
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was beyond helpful and responsive every step of the way. He did an incredible job setting up showings as soon as possible, providing support and advise with every offer, and going above and beyond to answer any questions.
Pnsaeger
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay is an exceptional real estate agent and his team is highly responsive and reliable throughout the closing process. He has excellent business acumen, expert knowledge of the buying and selling process, and very good negotiating skills. He has been a strong advocate for us, while also building rapport with the other party's agent. Cay also brings a network of skilled and reliable people for support, including contractors, painters, handymen, inspectors, escrow officers, etc... We have partnered with Cay and team on multiple buy and sell transactions. All were completed successfully with excellent results, and we were delighted with Cay & team's support every time.
Max B.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I'd say Cay is the one of best real-estate agent in San Diego. He helped to purchase my dream home in the Escondido area as a buyer's agent. With his proven expertise and extensive knowledge of San Diego/Escondido community, my offer was finally selected in fierce market competitions. He is very responsive and there was no hassle from the beginning of the deal to closure. Even after the closing, he actively listens and addresses any of my questions/concerns of property and community. I'd highly recommend him to my friends or anyone who'd be new home buyer or the seller.
User7678767
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay is an exceptional real estate agent and a true professional. During the process of finding a house, he listened attentively to our preferences and customized home searching based on our requirements. He was knowledgeable of the communities and housing market. He also had established relationships with other realtors. What we liked the most about him was his honesty. He was not pushy and always provided insightful advice that helped us comfortably make a decision. He was supportive, responsive, and trustworthy which helped us smoothly navigate the purchase process. His vast experience coupled with pleasant and calming personality minimized the stress associated with purchasing a house. Overall, his knowledge, expertise, and negotiation skills were simply impeccable. We wholeheartedly give him our highest recommendation.
Colin T.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I actually chose to go with Cay on a whim - I filled out a form on a site, and it matched me up with him. However, from the moment we first spoke, I knew we were in good hands. Cay came prepared with excellent knowledge of the areas we were looking, and even insights down to the zip code of how an area fared for our young family. He was very patient and thorough, and handled things like a true professional. When we began putting in offers, he handled negotiations with an eye towards honesty and fairness for all parties, while working to secure us the best deal possible. During closing proceedings he was close at hand and immensely helpful in making sure we were aware of what was going on, what to expect next, etc. All in all, he helped us secure a lovely home in an excellent area for our family, and did so with excellent communication, integrity, and dedication.I would wholeheartedly recommend Cay to anyone looking to buy or sell - you can't go wrong!
Melinda C.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED We met Cay a couple years ago at an open house showing. Cay was extremely professional and set us up with a personalized electronic search tool, that automatically sent us houses with our established criteria. Cay would check-in from time-to-time, but never pressured us. When we were finally ready to buy, Cay was extremely responsive and immediately booked the showings we requested. Once we were ready to make an offer, Cay looked out for our best interest and negotiated on our behalf. Cay is an 'expert' realtor, he is very knowledgeable of the market, and does an excellent job! We would highly recommend Cay to anyone searching for a customer focused and professional realtor. knowledgeable realtor.
Tom H.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was an excellent agent in helping us sell a difficult, distressed property. He quickly found a qualified buyer who was willing to work with our problem house. We couldn't be happier!
Dsc91179
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay is an outstanding agent to work with. He was responsive, understanding, patient, knowledgeable and caring. Cay was persistent in finding our family the home that best fit our needs and wants. He was also very strategic and sound when negotiating The Price of our new home. We cant say enough goods things about Cay and his team to describe how they made our journey of finding a home such a wonderful and memorable experience. We are truly appreciative of them and would recommend Cay and his team to anyone without hesitation.
Zuser20171015104811850
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Cay to sell our home was a wonderful experience. With Cays knowledge and expertise he was able to provide us with tips and suggestions that got us four offers over asking price within days of listing. With Cays help, guidance, and quick responses to any of my questions, escrow went as smooth as you could ask for. Could not be happier with choosing Cay Carly and Patrick as my real estate professional.
Maryvconlen
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was the perfect agent for us - professional, knowledgeable, honest and responsive. It had been 30 years since we sold our last primary residence and a lot had changed in the real estate process. We took his direction: decluttered, staged our home, completed our 'task list' and kept to his suggested time-line. The result? We were in escrow within a few days after choosing among several offers. Cay and his team protected our interests during escrow and the result was a quick and (relatively) painless 30 days. We had a lot of deferred maintenance and termite work to complete; Cay provided a list of reliable referrals who we contacted to quickly complete the work. I highly recommend Cay and his team...they delivered what he promised, and we are grateful. Did I mention he's also very patient? :)Mary Conlen and Lee Kromschroeder
Sgbrodie
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED "Cay is one of the most professional people I've known. He had an offer the day our home was being staged, but it didn't work out. However, within a few days our home sold for way over asking price. He had a plan for maximum exposer and our home was sold in 24 hours with multiple offers. Our home closed escrow in about 15 days. He did what he said he'd do. Was always available within a reasonable period of time and kept us informed throughout the process. I hold a California Real Estate Broker's License, but have not worked in many years. My wife and I did not want to sell our own home and we are so pleased we had Cay and the Team handle our transaction. I could not recommend them more highly.
Sfsmith8286
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I had an agent, but then bumped into Cay at a showing. I was impressed with his clear encyclopedic information on the greater San Diego area as well as his insight on the bizarre housing market during Covid. So I switched to Cay, and ended up buying a house within a couple of weeks. It was a smooth experience, and he was exceptionally attentive and active throughout the search, negotiations, and closure processes.He is also not a sale-and-goodbye guy...I continue to seek his recommendations on all sorts of things form handymen to flooring options. He's seen a lot, knows a lot and offers a lot! I absolutely recommend enlisting Cay's team for any purchase or sale.Maj Gen Scott Smith, USAF, (ret)
Ronp700005
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Great local knowledge. Excellent service. Wide range of respurces. Sold in less than 2 days above asking price. Great support throughout the process. No doubt about why Cay $ Carley are the premiere agents in this neighborhoodCouldn't ask for more!
Renee C.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED We hired Cay & his team to sell our home in March of 2020, the same week that the coronavirus pandemic shut down local schools and we were all asked to quarantine. During this uncertain time, Cay & his team kept in contact with us as we waited for a time when we felt comfortable to list our home later in May. Once we were ready to list, they hit the ground running to market and sell our home, and we had multiple offers to choose from in only a few days. Ultimately we were able to accept an offer for more than we had hoped for and Cay's team made the whole process seamless. Highly recommend. Thank you again!!
Bctorres7
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Team Cay, Carly and Patrick was recommended to us by a friend. We were thrilled with the result of their effort. Very professional, responsive and caring to the effort of selling our home. Their executive administrative assistant, Sheila, was helpful in providing the documents needed to navigate the offers and answer our questions. All of the recommendations to make our home more appealing to buyers paid off. You will not be disappointed with the team to sell your home or assist in purchasing your new home.
Kristinntucker
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I couldn't be happier with this home selling experience. We had previously listed our house with another realtor and it never sold after a year on the market. We switched and started working with Cay--he immediately hosted an amazing open house, and two days later we had multiple offers. With his knowledge and negotiation skills, our selling price wound up much higher than what we listed at. Cay's local presence and contractor network also made the whole process go smoothly. I am honestly stunned by how well this home sale went!
Lizsandersnyc
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED We were so fortunate to have been referred to Cay. He and his team went above and beyond expectations, facilitating every aspect of the sale of our family home - from staging to yard work to pool service - when we were out of state. Superb level of service and expertise. We could not have been more pleased with the process and excellent result. We also entrusted Cay to sell an additional property that we liquidated. He analyzes situations very well and makes practical, thoughtful recommendations. And he's also the very nicest person to work with! Thank you Cay for your guidance and support!
Dave7566
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay is by far the most diligent, professional, and patient Realator we have ever dealt with. After a 30+ military career this our 5th real estate transaction. His calm and steady demeanor was directly responsible for us selling our home of 10 years for the best and fairest price. I will always recommend Cay and his team with the highest praise. Well done Cay!
Msaguilera
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED This is our second experience with Cay. We sought him out again because he did such an excellent job for us before. We had not anticipated changing homes again but we found ourselves doing so and we called Cay right away. He is easy to work with. He knows his stuff. He is honest and ethical. And did right by us. If you need a realtor you should contact Cay.
Gebarnhart
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Lived in our neighborhood for years, met him a several open houses. Knows the 'hood, its demographics and how to sell. Brings in all the experts, knows the local contractors. This guy has been selling for years and knows it all. Priced it right, sold it in 45 days, 2% below asking.
Dennis L.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED As I close on a third real estate transaction in the previous four years utilizing Cay, I again, find him as a professional agent who is responsive and proactive to both my selling and buying goals. I highly recommend Cay and Team for your real estate goals.
Zuser20190316203844955
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED The 5 star experience doesnt end at purchasing your new home with this team. They are very well connected throughout San Diego, and when it comes to anything home improvement related, they always know who you can trust. I am so happy I used Cay as my agent. He and his wonderful team ensured this process was a smooth ride.
Dchristich
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED As I close on a third real estate transaction in the previous four years utilizing Cay, I again, find him as a professional agent who is responsive and proactive to both my selling and buying goals. I highly recommend Cay and Team for your real estate goals.
Victoria W.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED The 5 star experience doesnt end at purchasing your new home with this team. They are very well connected throughout San Diego, and when it comes to anything home improvement related, they always know who you can trust. I am so happy I used Cay as my agent. He and his wonderful team ensured this process was a smooth ride.
Bill07500
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Selling a house can be stressful, confusing, and taxing. I don't know how we would have fared so well (both emotionally and financially) without Cay leading us through the process. His team included a staging consultation prior to listing, which allowed us to address cosmetic issues we didn't notice, and present our home in its best light. Prior to listing we had a thoughtful and objective discussion regarding our pricing strategy which played a critical component in the successful outcome. The results speak for themselves: 70+ at the Open House, 5 excellent offers, successful closing at a very fair price within 20 days of the original listing. All of the above are probably high water marks for our neighborhood. We are grateful we selected Cay and his team to represent us.We are also grateful we engaged the services of Cay and his team in the purchase of our new home. He helped us navigate the entire process from loan qualification, home selection criteria, assessing the pros and cons of each home in contention, negotiating strategy, inspection, escrow processing, final walk through, to even the selection of a mover. Thank you Cay!
Jwelken3
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED With a limited amount of time to find and purchase a home in Carlsbad, Cay and Carly Homes provided great support to ensure we met our goal. Coming from out of state, Cay graciously accommodated two house hunting periods while Sheila was extensively called upon to explain various nuances of the escrow process. We truly appreciate the knowledge and expertise Cay and Sheila provided us in finding our new home.
Zuser20150729185050886
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay really helped us get our house ready for sale, and he worked with all the contractors to make it happen. He has great contacts for home improvements and getting you ready to move. very engaged throughout the process.
Doug S.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED After expertly closing the deal on the house my wife and I bought last October, we turned to Cay to handle the deal for our daughters first home purchase. The house was built in 1920 and presented some challenges that Cay expertly negotiated through. When our lenders incompetence threatened to sink the deal, Cays assistant Sheila saved the day. She expertly got the deal back on track and closed. This is the go-to team for home purchase. I would use no one else
Byongsamyi
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED My wife and I interviewed multiple realtors to sell our house and we selected Cay to represent our property. He was highly recommended by many other professionals when I mentioned that I was planning to sell the house. I thought it was a great testaments to Cay's expertise and professionalism. Cay consistently demonstrated the highest level of business integrity and his attention to detail was paramount in selling out home while we were out of town across the country. As his reputation preceded him, Cay met and exceeded our expectations. We highly recommend him and commend him for his professionalism and honesty.
User67946729
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay and Carly took over our listing after it had been on the market for 90 days with another agent. They suggested staging and hit the ground running with open houses and a new look listing.In a tough market with many, many open houses, Cay suggested a few minor changes to freshen the property up. The strategy worked and we had offers streaming in again. We finally sold for a fair price and are really happy to have met Cay! Great guy and always available for his clients.
Zuser20160920171616738
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED After making the decision to sell our home, it was without reservation that we selected Cay to represent our property. Selection of an agent that consistently demonstrated the highest level of business integrity; communication to all audiences involved; and unsurpassed area expertise outlined the criteria for our decision. As his reputation preceded him, Cay met and exceeded our expectations. Thank you so much, Cay, for your authentic excellence. .................SOLD
Dalefeine
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Having retired from the business world, my wife and I were looking for a Real Estate person who had a sound strategy for selling our home, was responsive to all events pre- and post-sale, and most important, would demonstrate a high degree of integrity throughout the process. We are very happy to acknowledge that Cay provided precisely these characteristics in the sale of our home. In addition, Cay helped us to find sources to stage and move our household to our next home. Cay and his team are highly recommended.
DeborahSampson3
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay and his team are everything I could wish for in the homebuying process. honest, forthcoming, and communicative are just some of the terrific adjective I can think of to describe Cay. Even after our house closed, Cay was still there to help with tying up any loose ends. I highly recommend using Cay and his team whether you are a buyer or a seller!
Zuser20180112093834041
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was absolutely wonderful! He was knowledgble, helpful and always available for questions or concerns. Patrick and the rest of the team were also great! Ending up finding the house of our dreams with their team
James0766
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was instrumental in getting our family out of our last home and into our new Dream Home. We had lived in our last home for almost 15 years. We raised two boys from babies to teenagers and it was wonderful for those beginning years, but we grew tired of the layout and wanted something different for our family going forward. Cay helped arrange contractors for our remodel, which was needed to bring our old home to market. He had a list of painters, plumbers and workers of all types to help get the job done. He orchestrated the sale of that home and helped us find the right fit for our new home. When it came to negotiations, Cay was brilliant in his plans. He was able to list and sell our home incredibly fast, for more money than we thought we could garner initially and helped us negotiate a speedy sale on the new house that we were anxious to move into. With Cay and his team in place, we were able to realize our dream and we are very happy in our new neighborhood. I would highly recommend Cay to anyone serious about selling or buying a home.
Jjcdcc
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED I found this realtor to be very conscientious, instructive, and diligent. The sale of the house went very smoothly thanks to the work performed by Cay at the onset of the listing and continued hands-on performance during and with the final actions after the house was sold. For instance, when we were left with furniture to be disposed of, they quickly proceeded to help with its disposal, finding a buyer for us. He is an honest, hardworking person, and was visible for anything that came up. Jessica, his office assistant was right there when we needed an answer or had a problem.
Kristen F.
Review for Member: Cay Bohnsack
ZillowVERIFIED Cay was in the unenviable position of representing both us and the seller. Not only was he very skilled in navigating the often emotionally charged process of buying and selling a home but he is fair. At no time did I feel that I was being unfairly represented or otherwise ignored. Cay and his team are very responsive to calls and requests for information, frequently calling back before I can even leave a voicemail. Things always go wrong or not as expected, and our purchase was not an exception. However, this is where Cay and his team show their true value by going the extra mile to make sure any mistakes are corrected and any miscommunications clarified. When everything is rosy, everyone is great. When the chips are down, you really know who you have working for you, and I would gladly work with Cay again! Ethical, reliable and pleasant!
