2026
Bayville, NJ
2018-2021 Circle of Excellence Sales Award
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was very professional, she was always available to answer questions, helping getting me documents on doc u sign. The sale went quickly and smoothly.
ZillowVERIFIEDI cannot express how grateful to have met Caroline. She was so knowledgeable in every aspect of selling my home. She gave a concise preparation timeline and game plan, then went out of her way to present it as if it was her own. Without her, I would have never found the perfect person to love my house as much as I do. There is no one better than her, trust me!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe cannot say enough amazing things about Caroline! As first time homebuyers, we had so many questions and honestly didnt know what to expect, but she made the entire experience feel smooth, organized, and even fun. Her communication was outstanding from start to finish. She was always quick to respond, explained everything clearly, and made sure we felt comfortable and confident in every decision. We never felt out of the loop, and that meant so much to us during such a big milestone. Caroline truly went above and beyond to make this process stress-free and exciting. We are so grateful for her guidance and support, and we would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. And shoutout to Caroline for the cutest gift to us on our closing day!!!
ZillowVERIFIEDIt really was great working with Caroline. Always so pleasant and helpful. All her connections were great and so helpful. She made the process of buying my home so easy. I would highly recommend her or anyone on her team to anyone looking for a home.
ZillowVERIFIEDI cannot say enough good things about Caroline. She made our whole real estate process from selling to buying a breeze. She works collaborative with you, listens to everything and only does whats best for your interest. Shes quick to respond and set up visits. You can tell how much she cares and values her clients and her job. She made a stressful task, enjoyable and easy. I would use Caroline over and over.
ZillowVERIFIEDI cannot say enough good things about my experience with Caroline and her team on my recent house sale and purchase. There was excellent communication from start to finish and any questions or concerns were handled promptly and efficiently. This process can be overwhelming, and she was literally right beside us every step of the way. Her entire team is top notch and their passion and love for what they do clearly shines through. We could not be any happier with the service we received and would 100% recommend her. Absolutely top-notch.
ZillowVERIFIEDI couldnt be happier with the experience of working with Caroline from our very first conversation to closing day. She is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping me find the perfect home. She took the time to understand exactly what I was looking for. Her guidance made the entire process smooth and stress-free. If you are looking for someone who truly cares and knows their business, I highly recommend Caroline and her real estate group. Thank you and James for helping me start this exciting new chapter!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline did an amazing job helping us sell our home in Browns mills! we had a bunch of hurdles along the way between having to expedite documents and even make a miracle happen having the certificate of occupancy inspection done the day before settlement due to the county being overloaded with inspections with only one inspector. Was in our corner the entire time and used alot of her contacts and references to get fair deals on repairs needed and required services to sell the home. We would highly recommend her to anybody looking to sell their home in new jersey.
ZillowVERIFIED11 out of 10. She's the very best! She knows all the ins and outs of the business, and she actually cares about her clients, their families, and the genuine relationships she has with them. Her entire business is built on referrals, and after working with her and alongside her it's very easy to see why. Caroline goes above and beyond for each and every client, so rest assured, that she will go above and beyond for you and your family.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe recently had the pleasure of working with Caroline Garguilo to purchase our new home in Monmouth County, and we cannot recommend her highly enough. Moving from Brooklyn, NY, we were unfamiliar with the area and the buying process here, but Caroline made everything smooth and stress-free. From the very beginning, she was attentive, patient, and incredibly knowledgeable about the neighborhoods, schools, and overall market. She took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for and guided us through every step with professionalism and care. Caroline was always available to answer our questions, big or small, and her responsiveness and clear communication gave us so much peace of mind. What truly stood out was how much she genuinely cared about finding the right home for our familyaEUR"not just making a sale. She advocated for us during negotiations, helped us navigate the inspection and closing process, and made sure we felt confident every step of the way. Thanks to Caroline, we found a wonderful home that we are excited to grow into, and we are so grateful for her guidance and dedication. If youre looking to buy or sell in Monmouth County, we wholeheartedly recommend working with Caroline Garguilo.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline is by far the best realtor my wife and I have ever dealt with. From the very beginning, she was extremely patient and informative, no pressure at all. Her attention to detail is extraordinary and follows through on everything she commits to doing. My wife and I were nervous selling and buying at the same time, but Caroline made the experience a pleasure. You truly get the sense she has her clients best interest at the forefront! Anyone looking to do a real estate transaction needs to contact Caroline. There is no doubt she will take care of you! Our experience was such a pleasure, I recommended her to my Mother and Stepfather, who loved her as well! DO NOT HESITATE, hire Caroline!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe were referred to Caroline through the Ramsey Trusted Provider network, and now we truly understand why shes on that list-shes exceptional! From the very start, Caroline guided us through the many twists and turns of the homebuying process with incredible expertise and calm confidence. She helped us navigate (and avoid!) potential pitfalls that we wouldnt have seen coming on our own. One of the things that really stood out was the amazing network of professionals shes built around heraEUR"everyone she recommended, from the inspector to the title company, was top-notch and made the entire process smoother and less stressful. Caroline made us feel like we were her only clients, even though we know she had others. Her dedication, responsiveness, and attention to detail were next-level. She truly listened and tuned into our needs, and it showsaEUR"we found a home thats absolutely perfect for us! She also has the heart of a teacher, walking us through each step with patience and clarity, and she brought some much-needed humor to the more stressful moments, which we so appreciated. We cant recommend Caroline enough. If youre looking for a realtor who is smart, kind, well-connected, and 100% on your team, shes the one!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe had such a great experience working with Caroline! From day one, she was friendly, easy to talk to and really listened to what we were looking for. Caroline made this whole process extremely easy and less stressful than we expected. Her knowledge and professionalism are top notch. She was quick to answer all our questions with patience and understanding. If you are looking for a realtor who is responsive, knowledgeable, friendly and genuinely cares about her clients, then Caroline is your person!! We will forever be grateful for making our dream home a reality!
ZillowVERIFIEDIf anyone else out there is looking to buy or sell a home I would 100% recommend Caroline as your Realtor. Not only did she know her job inside but she guided me through buying my first home at 20 years old, Caroline went above and beyond even on a personal level to ensure the deal would go through despite having a difficult seller. Caroline exemplifies a Christ like woman and will genuinely have your back throughout the entire process. Thank you again for everything Caroline and I would love to work with you again in the future!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was extremely professional, responsive, and an absolute pleasure to work with. She took quick action to help secure us with a reliable tenant to rent our condo. Caroline was helpful and informative, giving great advice and answered any questions in a prompt manner. I would highly recommend her to anyone interested in renting or selling their home.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline helped us find the perfect first home after a long search. She was speedy at setting up appointments to see homes and answered our questions along the way. We appreciated all of her help along our home buying journey!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was a fabulous real estate agent to work with. Her communication, personality, honesty, and willingness to listen allowed me to purchase my new property with ease. She was great at communicating with myself and my daughter throughout the entire buying process. It was a big decision to purchase a second home and Caroline went above and beyond to give us advice and allow our family to find the perfect beach house! She took into consideration everything we said and any questions or concerns we ever had about a property, which allowed us to trust her and enjoy working with her! I recommend Caroline to anyone looking for an enjoyable and easy real estate experience. Thank you so much Caroline!
ZillowVERIFIEDMy father and I have always dreamed of having a shore house for the summer where our families can spend time together. Caroline made that dream come true! She helped us find the perfect summer home in Lavallette, NJ. From the beginning to the end of our search process, Caroline was extremely knowledgeable, responsive and patient throughout everything. She took into account what we were looking for, and paid attention to every little detail. Her communication skills and dedication helped make the process of buying a home smooth and stress-free. We couldnt be happier with our new home, and with Caroline for making it an enjoyable and fun process!I would highly recommend Caroline to anyone looking for a real estate agent in the area. I know moving forward, anyone in my family will be using her as well!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was very helpful on closing on our home. She was in consistent communication with us and making sure we were informed every step of the way. I would highly recommend Caroline to sell your home!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline helped me find a great home. She is professional, responsive, and truly went above and beyond to ensure the process was smooth and stress-free.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was professional and in tune to what our wants and needs were. Always available and anxious to please you. Can't ask for a better realtor. Would totally recommend her . Her staff and whomever she recommends to guide you through your purchases are excellent and totally professional.
ZillowVERIFIEDId like to thank Caroline for helping us sell our family home. Caroline took us through every step and guided us w such professionalism. I am so thankful to have had her on our side in selling our home. I highly recommend her and her team. Thank you again.
ZillowVERIFIEDCarline did an amazing job with selling my ex husband and I condo. Caroline went above and beyond to make the process so easy to understand and told us everything that was being done with sell the condo. I will definitely have Caroline be my realtor again
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was a pleasure to work with. She is passionate and dedicated in finding me my forever home. Caroline was a great resource for all of my needs. Everyone that she recommended was professional which made the whole complicated experience seamless. I am a huge fan of Caroline because she went over and above to find me exactly what I was looking for.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline made the hard parts of getting the house ready for the market easier, and made everything happen at the pace that we needed to close the sale. I felt that she looked out for my needs at every step of the process, answered every question quickly and accurately, and put a team of seasoned professionals into play when we needed them. It was a comprehensively solid performance, and I am glad I chose her to represent me.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline is a phenomenal realtor. We found her through the Dave Ramsey approved realtor search and couldn't have been happier. Caroline went above and beyond to help us find our dream home as she helped us navigate various communities in central NJ and find credible builders and inspectors in the area. Caroline's local expertise is a game changer when it came to finding the community right for us. She also has fun events for her clients that help new homeowners feel more connected to their local communities. We felt supported and prepared for every step in our new home purchase. We would highly recommend Caroline to anyone looking to buy or sell their property.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline went above and beyond for us. Purchasing a home while living in another country wasn't easy but she made it happen. She gave us wonderful recommendations for everything we needed- inspector, contractors, lawyers. We are so happy with our new home. We would use Caroline again and again for our home buying process!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was so professional but also seemed like friend. It was a first time for me selling a house and she was so kind in walking me the whole way through until closing. She helped with phone calls and being a go between with her and their realtor. I listened to everything she said and my house was under contract in less than a week. She is the best!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline did an outstanding job helping us close on our home in Mystic Islands. She was precise, professional , and went above and beyond from start to finish . We look forward to using Caroline for future real estate deals!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline and her team were so easy to work with! She was very upfront on what to expect being a buyer in this difficult market. Her and her team were always quick to get showings scheduled. She is very knowledgeable, and she has a ton of contacts to help you during the process and after closing. Give her a call, you wont be disappointed!
ZillowVERIFIEDShe was fantastic from start to finish. She went the extra mile for us on every step of our home buying journey. We could not have done it without her, and we are so grateful for her assistance, patience and expertise. She is friendly and responsive. She would set up regular check ins, and always gives great advice. We had a difficult journey, full of ups and downs, at times ready to give up, but she kept us looking forward. She is trustworthy and reliable.
ZillowVERIFIEDI first met Caroline roughly 6 years ago at an open house. As much as I wanted to buy a house, I was not personally ready to do so. Over 6 years, Caroline stayed in contact and waited for the green light from me to start the house buying process. Not once did she push the process but more so trusted me to reach out when I was ready. Most think of realtors as sale agents, thats not Caroline. Caroline is a matchmaker. She introduced me to homes until I found the one I fell in love with. The first house I put an offer on was accepted right away and now I am in my forever home. I was recently asked why I chose to stay with Caroline after years of meeting her at an open house. Thats an easy answer, Caroline exemplifies a perfect realtor. Honesty and integrity, communication, knowledge of the housing process, and incredible negotiation skills are what Caroline brings to the table. It was an amazing experience I will never forget and I am truly blessed to have finally landed in my forever home. Thank you so much ??
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline did an outstanding job of describing the pros and cons of different shore towns. She listened to all of my questions and concerns and addressed them quickly. She was honest in her opinions on potential issues with some properties and did not hesitate to stear me away from problem properties even though it meant a potential loss of commission. She has continued to stay in contact with me months after the close to ensure everything is working out well for my family. I would not hesitate to recommend Caroline to anyone for their realtor needs.
ZillowVERIFIEDThis is long over due. I just want to thank you Caroline for everything you did. Even though it was a difficult time she made everything seem so easy. And when buying my now home its like she new exactly what I needed and wanted. I cant think of a more intelligent and caring individual. She really wants you to get you the house of your dreams and thrives off the happiness it brings you when she does. When it comes to realitors shes the best, but when it comes down to the person she is, shes the tops. Once again thank you for everything. Side note a good old Boston crA?me donut goes a long way ??
ZillowVERIFIEDI had to move out of state and Caroline was great! She took on many of the responsibilities that would typically be on the selling homeowner and got the job done. She also walked us through every step of the process and was always on top of things when we were busy. I will definitely be using her again for any real estate transactions that I have in the future.
ZillowVERIFIEDAbsolutely one of the best. From the time we meet till the very last day Caroline was there. Super knowledgeable and professional..sold my house in one day over asking price ..thanks again Caroline ????
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline and her team were exceptional. From searching to find a home through the inspection and closing, Caroline and her contacts were professional and extremely knowledgeable. I highly recommend Caroline for all of your real estate needs.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was kind enough to meet with me when I was in the beginning stages of considering the sale of my home. It was a very scary time in my life, as I was going through a divorce and would also need to find a place to live as a newly single mom with two young children. Carolines knowledge, confidence, and honesty were everything I needed to make this move. She was able to sell our home AND find me my dream home in my price range. She truly helped me achieve what I thought was impossible. Caroline is professional, honesty, and cares about her clients. If you are looking to buy or sell your home, I highly recommend giving Caroline a callaEUR|she is the BEST!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe met Caroline and her team through close mutual friends. Originally, we were living 3 hours out of state and looking to purchase a home in New Jersey. We felt comfortable from the start with her warm, down to earth personality and eagerness to help us find a home. The New Jersey market is difficult, especially since the inventory is low and the prices have significantly increased in the past few years. We're very detail oriented people and weren't willing to settle on just anything, so we took our time and looked at many options. Despite the market and our meticulous eye, Caroline was always able to meet with us to show us houses, sometimes even with very short notice (Thank you!). She was also always very honest and transparent with us, which we appreciate, since as the professional, she knew what it would take to make a deal happen. It took us just under a year to find what we wanted, but she was able to get us closed on our home under list price! Caroline also set us up with other wonderful professionals to make our closing go smoothly. We are happy to officially be back in NJ, thanks to her hard work, time and dedication.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was amazing to work with! She helped guide us in navigating big decisions we needed to make regarding our investment property which we couldn't have done without her. Once we decided to re-list our property as a rental and market it for new tenants all while living abroad ourselves, Caroline went above & beyond in supporting us through the process & securing amazing tenant applications for us to choose from. She made the process absolutely seamless & we had immense trust in her integrity, professionalism and competence to guide us through the process from afar. We would highly recommend her in any capacity as a realtor!
ZillowVERIFIEDThe process of buying our first home with Caroline was so smooth! She was able to educate us on everything we needed to know about the market and gave us some amazing tips and tricks along the way. Caroline and her team were with us every step of the way to make our first time home buying experience something we will never forget. In the best way possible! We will definitely be recommending her and her team to everyone looking to buy a home.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was recommended to us by a friend. My wife and I couldn't have been more pleased. Caroline met with us in the beginning to talk, get to know each other, discuss game plan, and talk about our so called wish lists. Caroline was energetic, enthusiastic and professional. We were looking in Monmouth and Ocean Counties, which she was able to help in every way. The school systems meant a lot to us and she was able to share a lot. When it came to offers, Caroline guided us thru the process as it was our first house. She really made a tough and stressful process easy for us. It was a stressful time for my wife and I and Caroline kept us smiling and was very positive thru out. That was important because as we learned there are let downs during the home buying process. In the end, Caroline got the deal done for us and we couldn't be happier. We love Our new home! Thank you Caroline!!! B & P
ZillowVERIFIEDIn June of 2022 we worked with Caroline Garguilo, owner of CG Realty Group and part of Keller Williams Realty in selling our home. That experience was so awesome and easy that we reached out to her to help us find our new home. Caroline made finding and buying our new home so easy and stress free. She did the research in finding a home based on criteria we set forth. She worked with our lender, home inspector, attorney and even recommended an insurance provider that saved us money on home insurance. Caroline also worked very closely with the sellers realtor to make sure every little detail was complete. On March 1st 2023 we closed on our new home and could not be happier. Working with Caroline and her team was extremely professional and more importantly "friendly". I would highly recommend contacting Caroline if you are looking to buy or sell your home. I just can't say enough.
ZillowVERIFIEDAs first time homebuyers, we could not have picked a better realtor than Caroline! She was patient and answered all of our questions, always sharing options on how to best navigate different obstacles. Caroline made us feel comfortable throughout the entire process from beginning to end. Even sharing her contacts and helping us find our lawyer and inspector. On top of being amazing at what she does, she was extremely kind and fun to find a house with. I highly recommend working with Caroline!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline helped me sell my house in the spring of 2022 while I was in the midst of a life changing event. She was a dream to work with and was able to sell my house over asking! She was the obvious choice when it came time to buy my next house! Her positivity and keen eye made the house shopping process a breeze! Once we found the house we loved, Caroline and her associates worked their magic to get us into the home my girlfriend and I will raise our child in! I couldnt be more grateful for Carolines help through two major life changing events! She is amazing at what she does and I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy a home!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline is in excellent real estate agent who no matter when you try to contact her she gets back to you right away. She's very knowledgeable and sold my house within a week. I got over $10,000 more than what I was asking. Very happy and would recommend her.
ZillowVERIFIEDWhat can we say that would be enough to praise this incredible person who also happens to be a fantastic Real Estate agent? Caroline came to us after we had almost made our choice to go with another agent. We are so glad we had her come and present to us her plan to sell our house. She was so professional, and used amazing technology that made it so easy to know what was going on. She was available to answer questions and when the deal was faltering figured out a way to make all parties work together to close the deal with everyone satisfied. Thank you Caroline!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline did an awesome job finding the perfect home for us. She was always professional and knowledgeable. She was a pleasure to work with with great communication and transparency throughout the entire process. We highly recommend working with Caroline. Her enthusiasm and passion for her customers is why we would work with her again.
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline was absolutely amazing and we can not recommend her enough! She was a friends recommendation and was so incredibly helpful with our home search, from start to finish. She got us over asking on our house which allowed us to afford our dream home. There was never a time when we felt she was being anything less than completely honest and all of her advice was spot on from staging and pictures, to the open house and price. When we expressed frustration with hiring local experts, we received excellent recommendations which literally made all the difference in our home search and eventual purchase. Could not be more pleased with our experience and would highly recommend Caroline to anyone searching for a realtor in New Jersey!
ZillowVERIFIEDCaroline made the selling of our home such a great experience. From our first sit down going over what to expect and all the way through the process to the close was so easy and stress free. - Caroline new my neighborhood and surrounding areas and provided us with advice on how to price our home- She provided us with a photographer and videographer, staged our home and the pictures were amazing-She was always available via text or email and we never had to wait long for a response- Caroline worked directly with the buyers realtor and handled all of the negotiating and bargaining that geos with the house. We never had to prompt her to do anything.-The showing of our home was the easiest of all as we were supplied an app to confirm or deny any appointments which took all of the stress of being ways from our home while being shown.-We had over 17 individual showings and 2 open houses - We have bids in for our home within 5 days and accepted a best and final offer 7 days after listing.- We received well over our asking price and could not be happier- We decided to rent while Caroline is now helping us with our new search and purchase of our new home.I would highly recommend using Caroline to sell or search for a new home.
Loading recent sales...
