Cara Huffman Top real estate agent in New Castle

Cara Huffman

FC Tucker/Cross
13 Years of Experience
(38)
$10.5M
Total Sales Last Year
13
Years of Experience
130
Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years
$186.1K
Average Price Point
  • Service Areas
  • Recent Sales
  • Contact Information
  • Social Media
  • Specialities
  • Awards
  • Available Listings

Specialties

  • Sellers
  • Residential Property
  • Commercial Property

Awards

  • award image
  • rewards

    2025

    TOP AGENT

    New Castle, IN

  • rewards

    2025

    TOP AGENT

    Shirley, IN

  • rewards

    2025

    TOP AGENT

    Hagerstown, IN

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 159

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

  1. 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
  2. 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Date
Address
Price
Represented
09/16/2025
2 Saint Marys Cir Winchester, IN 47394
Sold For $280K
09/16/2025 Buyer
09/15/2025
901 N Greenbriar Rd Muncie, IN 47304
Sold For $187K
09/15/2025 Seller
09/05/2025
3116 Hickory Ln New Castle, IN 47362
Sold For $249.9K
09/05/2025 Seller
08/18/2025
5082 E County Road 400 S New Castle, IN 47362
Sold For $322K
08/18/2025 Both

Cara Huffman's Reviews & Ratings

38 Reviews
(4.9/5)
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
  • Responsive
  • Professional
  • Knowledgeable
  • Communicative
  • Trustworthy
  • Attentive
  • Hard working
  • Outstanding
  • Available Remotely
  • Great for new buyers

Kayley Zercher

Review for Member: Kayley Zercher
July 19, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

Absolutely terrible, from trying to schedule a showing all the way through, awful experience. She lacks moral values and clearly doesn't follow a code of ethics in the work she does, F.C. Tucker should be ashamed that this is one of the realtors representing their company, I will not do business with them at all after this experience, specifically deleted every listing I had saved that had either of their names or representation present in the listing because I don't want another horrible experience and that is exactly what they have proven to be about!

Huntdanielle121297

Review for Member: Huntdanielle121297
December 15, 2023
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

Cara was with us every step of the process even after closing to help in anyway we needed. She never hesitated to meet to look at a house even if it was early in the morning on a weekend. We appreciate her taking exceptional care of us during our home buying process!

Smdavisson1

Review for Member: Smdavisson1
March 3, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

Cara was a joy to work with in the process of buying our first home! She was very kind and helpful! She was quick to respond and to answer our numerous questions. We would gladly recommend her to anyone!

Horandl

Review for Member: Horandl
January 30, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

I was a recent widow needing to downsize. Cara was recommended by my neighbors who had just sold their home with her assistance. Cara researched and found the value of my home. We put it up for sale. She showed it and we got some low offers. I ask her each time is my house worth what were asking and she reassured me it was she told me to hang in there. I held out for the price I wanted. She sold my home for the asking price. Cara has the knowledge and the persistence to get the job done. She was professional and friendly. That house was my life I was overwhelmed with the thought of leaving but I put it all in her hands and she took care of all the details. I needed a professional and I got one. I'm thankful she was there to help me over that hurdle in my life.

Denney217

Review for Member: Denney217
January 22, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
zillowZillowVERIFIED

Cara was exceptional, guided me though the entire process, answered any questions, gave great suggestions and we closed the deal very quickly. We sold the house very close to what we listed. Couldn't ask for anything more.. Will definitely give her a call when I buy or sell another home. Thanks Cara.