Caitlin Schlaffer Top real estate agent in Sparta

Caitlin Schlaffer

Keller Williams Integrity
4 Years of Experience
(42)
$0
Total Sales Last Year
4
Years of Experience
73
Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years
$453.9K
Average Price Point

    About Caitlin Schlaffer

    Creative Marketing. Expert Negotiation. Maximum Results. As a top-producing Sussex County real estate agent, Caitlin Schlaffer helps sellers navigate the market with creative marketing strategies and expert negotiation skills. She knows how to generate strong buyer interest, drive competitive offers, and get homes sold for top dollar. With a proven track record and deep local expertise, Caitlin is the go-to agent for homeowners looking for the most amount of money with the least amount of hassle! Thinking about selling? Call Caitlin today to discuss your strategy.
    Community Involvement
    I'm actively involved in my community as a sponsor and coach for the High Point Midget Cheer and Football League, supporting local youth athletics each year. I've also volunteered as a dog foster and volunteer with Eleventh Hour Rescue. Professionally, I served as the chairperson for the Sussex County Association of Realtors Young Professionals Network and currently sit on the Keller Williams ALC committee, helping to guide and support fellow agents.
    HOBBIES/INTEREST
    Avid reader. True crime junkie. Artist & crafter. Mom (human & fur babies). Cheerleading coach. Coffee lover. Not a mermaid, but wish I was... long walks by water!
    FAMILY
    Proud mother and wife and dog mom of Gus, Greta & Zeke.
    Read More About Caitlin

    Credentials

    LICENSE
    Real Estate - New Jersey - # 2183334
    Designation

    Real Estate Investing

    Seller Representative Specialist

    Licensed Realtor

    REALTOR

    Specialties

    • Buyers
    • Sellers

    Awards

    • award image

    Other Awards

    New Jersey REALTORS Circle of Excellence Sales Award, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024

    View All Awards

    Loading recent sales...

    Caitlin Schlaffer's Reviews & Ratings

    42 Reviews
    (5/5)
    Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
    What clients say about this agent....
    • Responsive
    • Communicative
    • Knowledgeable
    • Professional
    • Outstanding
    • Hard working
    • Trustworthy
    • Attentive
    • Available Remotely
    • Excellent negotiator

    Abbey Ryan

    Review for Member: Abbey Ryan
    October 1, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Caitlin was our agent in selling our home and purchasing a new one, all within a few months. She did an absolutely incredible job from the time we met her to the closing. When she first arrived to talk with us about selling the house, she came very prepared with comps, a booklet for us to look through and understand and she was very professional, and most importantly kind. She worked with us on pricing, she was honest and did an amazing job with selling our home, 50k over asking! In the purchase of our new home, we were also able to get it 40k under asking, which is an incredible deal in Lake Mohawk. Throughout the process she was always available, explained everything thoroughly and was very assertive when she needed to be. Shes the epitome of professionalism and Id recommend her to anyone and everyone I know. Selling and buying is so stressful, but Caitlin took care of absolutely everything and took such a burden off our shoulders. We love her!!

    Melissaandallan

    Review for Member: Melissaandallan
    June 26, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    It took us over 3 years to find our new home and Caitlin stuck by us through the whole process. Once we were under contract, she helped us through the entire process right up until the papers were signed. We never felt pressured through the process and Caitlin was incredibly patient with us through every step. We highly recommend her. You wont regret it.

    Higginsj1121

    Review for Member: Higginsj1121
    February 27, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    From start to finish, Caitlin was an expert, on top of every little detail to ensure a smooth, speedy listing and close, all while attracting a HUGE amount of buyers. Not only is she a true stand out in her field, she fits right in, like Ive known her for 20+ years!! I would HIGHLY recommend Caitlin to anyone looking to buy or sell!! (Thank you, Caitlin, for all of your help and guidance!)

    User1665161

    Review for Member: User1665161
    January 2, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    You know when you meet someone and you can just tell that they dont just show up to work for the paycheck, but are actually passionate about their work? Thats Caitlin- dedicated, knowledgeable, organized and caring. We sold and purchased a home with Caitlin and her support throughout a unusually stressful process was unmatched. If you are looking for a realtor who will get the job done, while also gaining a lifelong friend, look no further than Caitlin!

    Agslavin

    Review for Member: Agslavin
    December 21, 2024
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Caitlin was a incredible and invaluable asset in our home selling and buying experience. Our sale was hampered by numerous road blocks, an emergent birth and countless other obstacles along with dealing with a difficult purchase of our new forever home. Caitlin was supportive, informative and worked tirelessly to ensure my family got the best possible deal on our sale and put us in our dream home! Don't walk, RUN to hire Caitlin for your real estate experience.

    FAQ

    Contact Information

    Location

    25 Center Street #101 Sparta, NJ, 07871

    Social Media

    Trusted Professionals

    Trusted Pro

    Caitlin Schlaffer is a Trusted Pro with a network of verified professionals.

    Annmarie Schlaffer

    Loan Officer

    Mark Scocco

    Loan Officer

    More Agents Near You