Bethany Wager-Mckee

Agnes I. Wager Realty Inc

25 Years of Experience

(36)

$11M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$388.4K

Average Price Point

Service Areas
About
Credentials
Recent Sales
Contact Information
Social Media
Specialities

Service Areas

Burlingham, NY Hyde Park, NY Marlboro, NY Pine Bush, NY Plattekill, NY Poughkeepsie, NY Poughquag, NY Summitville, NY Wallkill, NY Wappingers Falls, NY

View All Service Areas

About Bethany Wager-Mckee

Real Estate Broker (24 years experience) Specialties Buyer's agent Listing agent Relocation Staging Agnes I. Wager Realty became the first real estate office own solely by a women broker in Dutchess County NY. Agnes (Aggie) Wager opened Agnes I. Wager Realty in 1957. I have warm memories of playing on her office floor and listening to the bustling office around me. In 1995 I earn my first Real Estate License in WA State. Shortly after I moved back to the Hudson Valley and within a year obtained my Brokers license. In 1999, I incorporated Agnes I. Wager Realty and have continued running the company to this present day! In my Real Estate Career, I have focused on helping people get into their first home and then continue to help over the years as they successfully move up the Real Estate ladder. I thoroughly enjoy helping people achieve their dreams. In addition to selling Real Estate, I was president of an appraisal company called The Appraisal Source. During the late 90's- early 2000's I took a break to be a Loan officer for American Home mortgage and later Guaranteed Home Mortgage. Through my endeavors, I have a well-rounded multidisciplinary background and can smoothly navigate through the ins and outs of the entire Real Estate Transaction. What do I do for fun??? In addition to being a Mom of 5 boys and recently a Grandma, I volunteer for multiple animal shelters. I am a singer with my husband in a rock band and above all else, I am crazy about horses!!!!!!! As a listing or buyer's agent, I will work to make your Real Estate experience as positive and stress-free as possible. I look forward to meeting you!

Credentials

LICENSE

Real Estate - New York - # 31OD0899518

Designation

CPRES

Top Producer

Real Estate Broker

Broker / Associate Broker

REALTOR

Specialties

Sellers
Commercial Property
Mobile Homes
Residential Property

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Poughkeepsie, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Hyde Park, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Marlboro, NY

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 106

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.

Date

Address

Price

Represented

10/14/2025

74 Hapeman Hill Red Hook, NY 12571

Sold For $350K

10/14/2025 Buyer

10/06/2025

11 Schuyler Dr Red Hook, NY 12571

Sold For $849K

10/06/2025 Buyer

09/09/2025

33 Whiteford Drive Pleasant Valley, NY 12569

Sold For $495K

09/09/2025 Buyer

06/17/2025

94-98 Lasher Road Big Indian, NY 12410

Sold For $79.4K

06/17/2025 Both

Bethany Wager-Mckee's Reviews & Ratings

36 Reviews

(4.4/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Responsive
Professional
Communicative
Knowledgeable
Outstanding
Trustworthy
Great for new buyers
Excellent negotiator
Hard working

Debra Serio

Review for Member: Debra Serio

October 5, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Gynell was very instrumental in helping us find our perfect home. We are new to NY and we didnt know where to begin in our search. Gynell helped guide us thru the areas we thought we were interested in and helped us hone in on exactly what we wanted! We will be occupying our new build home next February, but its worth the wait. Gynell helped us get everything we ever wanted in a homeaEUR|and more. She has tremendous local knowledge, excellent negotiating skills, shes patient, honest and an excellent listener. Gynell is a very hard worker and we recommend her 100%

Michael McWilliams

Review for Member: Michael McWilliams

December 23, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Zillow connected me to her through their automated system. She answered the phone and she said she'd send me a MLS for the property I was interested in and she didn't. She first said she send it the next day, because she was traveling. This was understandable, but then, she said she'd send it to me later that evening. I wasn't expecting it that evening. However, she didn't send it that evening or the next day.

Closetindustries

Review for Member: Closetindustries

August 18, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Beth is very patient and took us to any properties before we found "the one". She is very knowledgeable and knows her business well. And if she doesn't know, she finds out PDQ! She helped us through the whole process and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking in the Hudson Valley!

Carl Q Smith1973

Review for Member: Carl Q Smith1973

July 30, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

She was very unprofessional and disorganized. It was impossible to get return calls and she seemed to struggle with simple questions. It?s hard to believe she?s been in the business as long as she claims. I would not recommend her to my friends.

Dvishnep

Review for Member: Dvishnep

July 24, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

This real estate agent disappeared without any communication, after I tried to schedule visit to visit the property. Multiple text messages were ignored. Not recommended.