Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Leslie9166
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIEDWorking with Amy was an absolute blessing. Selling my mothers home was emotional, but Amy handled every step with professionalism, patience, and compassion. From the first meeting, she made the process feel effortless, offering honest advice, handling every detail, and going above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly. Amy truly cared about our familys situation, communicated constantly and made sure we always felt supported and informed. Thanks to her dedication and expertise, the house sold quickly and for over asking! I cant recommend her enough for anyone looking for a realtor who is not only skilled but genuinely cares about their clients. Thanks again Amy!
Thu H.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was our buyer's agent when we bought our house in 2018 and was our seller's agent when we sold our house recently in 2025. She is highly knowledgeable about the market conditions. She worked very hard in showing our house to 23 potential buyers. We sold our house 6 days after listing. She made sure the process moved along smoothly through closing. We highly recommend Amy to anyone looking to buy or sell a house!
20162667
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was beyond wonderful to work with. She not only sold our house, but also found us a home to purchase. Her expertise in knowing the market is impressive and she goes above and beyond. Amy is extremely responsive and provided us a lot of suport throughout this process, navigating unexpected situations. It's obvious that Amy loves her job and works hard to do her best for her clients.
Erbz221
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED This was the second home Amy assisted us on selling. Her experience and knowledge of marketing helped us achieve the best price for the homes. Her connections with quality contractors, lawyers and professionals made the preparations for sale and closing easy and seamless. Amy communicated with us regularly, keeping us updated and informed at all times. Her professionalism, expertise and positive enthusiasm made the process of selling as simple and straightforward as possible. We would highly recommend Amy to anyone interested in buying or selling real estate
Kpthornton45
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was great from the first moment I spoke with her. Shes so personable and immediately made us feel comfortable. We worked with her as buyers and sellers and her expertise made the entire process seamless. Additionally, she had a terrific team and was able to recommend some other people to work with that have all been great. I would highly recommend her!
Jamie C.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy came highly recommended and did not disappoint. She was very knowledgeable of the area and helped us navigate buying a house from a distance. She went above and beyond throughout the entire process and made a stressful process much smoother. We would highly recommend Amy Petrone to anyone moving to the Rochester area.
InvincibleGeorge
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy helped us sell our house quickly a few years ago and we had a great experience with her. She was very professional, knowledgeable, dedicated and kind. When we decided to sell our property this time, we had no doubt that Amy would be the best agent to assist us. As expected, Amy was able to sell our property quickly. We highly recommend Amy!
Vicmoynihan
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED As first time home buyers, Amy guided us every step of the way. She was always available to answer questions and help us navigate whatever came up during our home search. The market was extremely competitive, but Amy helped us find a home in an amazing neighborhood!!
Perichey
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy's professionalism and expertise are unsurpassed. Her marketing skills were evident in the listing and selling of our townhouse. She explained the process well and assisted us in answering questions and providing feedback every step along the way. Amy is easy to work with and promptly responds to inquiries from prospective buyers as well as the seller.
Jimkellyg5
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is the consummate professional. When it was time for my parents to move to a senior living facility, Amy helped us sell their home of 56 years. This was no small feat, given a short time frame and the fact that I live 400 miles away. Amy took the reins and made the process smooth and seamless. Her knowledge of the market was impressive and spot on. She guided us through every step of the process, recommended services and resources and went above and beyond to ensure my parents felt as comfortable as possible. We received seven strong offers and were so grateful that Amy and her team marketed the house so perfectly. We were blown away by the photographs and video tour! Amy was kind and compassionate to my parents in this difficult transition. Her amazing communication skills made me forget that she was in another state! I highly recommend Amy and her team if you are buying or selling in the Rochester area. She will get the job done.
Scottelaine29
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED How do you sell a house when you live 500 miles away during a global pandemic? Just call Amy Petrone. I live in Maine and it was time to put our family house on the market, which our parents had owned for 50+ years. It was clear that I needed a broker that was willing to put in a little extra time and help. While I could travel back and forth to clean out the house, I needed help finding movers, cleaners, plumbers, painters, etc. in order to get the house ready to sell. Amy was able to refer me to excellent people. She and her team were a huge help through the entire process. They would check on the work being done and send pictures. Another plus was that the photographer/ videographer did an excellent job. Amy managed the entire sales process for us. She is a great communicator and can do person. She knows the housing market, has excellent marketing and social media skills. Four days on the market, we had six offers.
Ahmed D.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy and her great team are EXTRAORDINARY!!! They made our selling process so easy and helped us understand what was happening every step of the way. We moved to Rochester in the middle of the sale during a tight market and only a few houses available, but TEAM PETRONE went above and beyond to help us find our amazing house. Amy's commitment to making sure we were well taken care of was just AMAZING!. Thank you so much, AMY and TEAM PETRONE!
Jamie F.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was nothing short of amazing. We were relocating and unfamiliar with our new city. She gave us a personalized tour of the area and got us in to see multiple houses that same day, one of which was off market. She even gave us a ride to the airport afterwards! When we ended up putting an offer in on the off market home, she had great advice and negotiating skills. Our offer was accepted within day and she seamlessly coordinately a remote closing. While in escrow, Amy also kindly referred us to contractors and painters and met them at the home while I FaceTimed her to discuss our plans. She and her team then checked on our house once a week until we moved in six month later! All of this would be more than enough to give five stars, but recently we had a washing machine emergency and she immediately helped give recommendations for repair companies. Amy truly went above and beyond in every aspect of our home buying experience here in Rochester. Despite being enormously busy, she conducted every step personally, and added thoughtful touches along the way. She is a master at what she does and if we ever have a need for a realtor again in the future, we will absolutely be using Amy.
Karaschweid
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED 5/5!!! Amy was so excellent to work with. She is incredibly knowledgeable about the Rochester market and is very easy to communicate with. We knew we were in great hands when she and Julia helped us find a perfect home. Also really appreciated her sharing many referrals to help link us with a handyman and lawyer. We highly, highly recommend her and we can't wait to together again!
Jeff B.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is a superb realtor! Professional, highly skilled, great communicator, and an excellent negotiator. Combined with Amy's knowledge of the local market buying our house was a wonderful experience. I highly recommend
Findahomeyl
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED My wife and I were the "first time seller" if you will. Amy and her team helped us and sold our house, made the entire process so smoothly and easy. From preparing, staging, showing, negotiating, final walking through, to closing, Amy accurately estimated the asking price, adjusted the initial showing plan promptly, made herself available in answering many questions we had even during weekends or evenings, and provided lots of guidances and advices on many steps we were taking. We felt so lucky to have Amy and her team. Overall, it was a phenomenal job and great success. We'd use here again without any hesitation and we'd love to recommend Amy to people who are either selling or purchasing their home in Rochester NY area.
Zuser20180102121504615
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was extremely helpful with our house purchase. She knew the local market and helped us find our forever home. She listened to what we were looking for and helped us find the perfect neighborhood. Even with a very competitive market, Amy helped us craft a successful offer and guided us through every step. She has given us local references and has reached out and been available even after the sale. Amy is professional and fun to work with.
Sshepard275
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy and her team were amazing in helping us sell our house as we moved state. They provided assistance in prepping and showing our home, and answered all of our questions as they came up. Once listed, our home sold quickly and the process could not have been easier. We recommend Amy to anyone looking to purchase or sell in the Rochester NY area.
ErinnDuprey7
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED We had a phenomenal experience buying our new home with Amy! She is so knowledgeable and helped us buy our dream home and navigate this tricky market. Once we secured our offer she also helped us find a contractor, painters, cleaner, and the list goes on. Plus she?s just a great, fun person to work with! I would highly recommend her as a realtor to anyone.
Mazzarellajulie
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy and her team are hands down 5 stars! She is responsive, professional, and knows the local market well. I would use Amy again and would recommend her to family and friends.
User6655458
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy came highly recommended to us by a friend who had used her to purchase a home several years ago. She has a perfect balance of personality and professionalism, and exceeded our expectations in every way. From her knowledge of the area and relationships with other local professionals, to her multiple solutions to any bump we encountered along the way, she made purchasing a home, out of state and sight unseen, feel easy! We highly recommend Amy and plan to use her for any purchase or sale we make in the future.
Kathleen R.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy Petrone helped to make my time in Rochester enjoyable. From helping me to find an apartment, then my home and, finally, to selling my home, she works tirelessly to make it happen. Amy and her capable team were available day and night to help me ready my home for sale. From guiding any needed renovations to negotiation, inspection, and closing, she fully supports her clients. Her knowledge of the local real estate market, responsiveness to calls, and negotiating skills are impressive. I have gladly referred several friends for whom she has also found new homes. Amy even went so far as to help me to find a realtor in the city to which I relocated!
Mkzeeff
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED She was Friendly, professional, great with communication and timely replies throughout the selling process. Utilized all resources possible to ensure a quick sale and a great price. We wanted someone to work with us from start to finish and she delivered that experience.
InvincibleGeorge
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is very professional, efficient and nice to work with! We highly recommend Amy and will definitely have her represent us in our future real estate transactions.
Dochoten
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is lovely, energetic but not pushy, and easy to deal with. She was very knowledgeable about our neighborhood. It was a very positive experience and I can highly recommend her.
Vergiliashirley
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy recently sold two houses for us. She is professional, a great listener, and very easy to work with. She gave us much insightful information and was also in touch with us during the entire process. Her negotiation skills are top-notch. I must say that she didnt miss a beat and we could not be more pleased with her knowledge, professionalism, and kindness. You will definitely be delighted in working with her.
Wnichols V.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is the best! She made our experience easy, and was very professional throughout the entire process - even in this insane market! My wife and I highly recommend her.
AndyH32
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED The absolute best!! We couldn't have had a better experience and can't thank her enough for all of her help. She is extremely knowledgeable, incredibly responsive, and would highly recommend her services.
Asvveas
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was, from the start, so professional and personable!. Her knowledge not only of the immediate neighborhood local area, but overall market was current, and correct. She and her associates/whole team helped make the process from staging, showings and marketing a smooth experience .I would and do highly recommend that you consider Amy Petrone if you are looking to buy or sell in Rochester, NY area
Jgomez05
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED If you are looking for a realtor who will guide you through the process, knows the market and will be creative when listing your home...Amy Petrone is your person! Amy sold my home in 4 days above asking price with multiple offers. She was always professional, knowledgeable and accessible. Selling your home can be a hectic process but Amy made it seamless!
561mcruz
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Thanks to Amy Petrones expertise in real estate and people skills, she sold our home in 1 day. From the moment we met Amy, she provided a clear vision of the selling points, and assurance of her ability to accomplish the sale along with her hand picked team. Amy and her team are impressive and talented. Very professional!! If there were more than 5 stars to rate...Amy would get the highest!! We appreciate Amy Petrone!
Aaron H.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is wonderful- smart, attentive, proactive and compassionate. There?s simply no way I would have been able to do this without her! Amy was definitely the steady and calming professional I needed to get this deal done and I?m incredibly appreciative. Highly recommend.
Patrick D.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy worked with my family over the course of almost two years, helping us relocate from Austin to Rochester. She was patient throughout the entire process, and always made sure to keep us informed when a property that fit our criteria was about to hit the market. We moved in the middle of a pandemic and were not able to actually travel to NY to see the house in person before we bought it. We put a high degree of trust in Amy to guide us through the home virtually (numerous times) and get us under contract and she handled everything we threw at her. I cant recommend Amy enough to anyone (local or out of state) looking to either buy or sell a home. Weve worked with five realtors over the last 10 years and she was by far the most professional, efficient, and helpful.
212krice
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED I could not have imagined working with anyone other than Amy! Her bio is true to every word. Amy made our first time home purchase a breeze and made us feel reassured and supported each step of the way. She always had sound advice, recommendations, and ideas to best fit what we were looking for. Our home feels perfect in so many ways. I would recommend Amy in a heartbeat and trust she can find a home (and close quickly!) for anyone.
Lindastumm
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy did an amazing job selling my moms condo !She is knowledgeable, professional and responsive ! She gave me the best recommendations for professionals to help such as Windows replaced , tub reglazed. Amy was always acccessable for questions , day or night . With her years of experience I knew I was in good hands. I highly recommend Amy Petrone for anyone who needs to buy or sell their home ! Another added plus , she sold the house above asking in one weekend !
Rochelle R.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is an absolute delight to work with and has been incredibly helpful and attentive throughout our entire house selling process. She was calm and completely on top of all of the changes in processes and rules in the middle of a pandemic. She provided excellent guidance on preparing and staging the house for sale, marketing to buyers, handling showings and finalizing the sale. We highly recommend Amy. She is such a pleasant person and we are so thankful for all she has done for us to make our home sale an easy one.
Robmischler
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED The Amy Petrone Team were fantastic throughout the entire process. My initial meeting gave me comfort in their professionalism, ability and experience. They had a great feel for the market overall, suggested/provided strong matches for initial pricing and helped me prioritize what needed to be done prior to the sale. A number of items required contractors to assist and they had strong referrals on the ready to contact. Marketing of the home was very proffessional and they utilized the latest technology to display online. As a result, we received multiple offers in just a day or two and the negotiations went very smooth. Overall communication and accessibility was excellent. Both she and Julia Furano were always available and on top of it! Great experience for sure......
Hirushi W.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED I had to sell the house while I was out of state and Amy was so helpful that the process was smooth.She is very reliable.She provides a professionals stager and photographer.
Shannon2277
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is truly amazing! She obtained multiple offers on my home and sold it for above asking price within days of listing it! She is highly knowledgeable, extremely professional, attentive and detail oriented. She demonstrated a genuine concern to work with me to sell my home. Working with her was a seamless process! I would highly recommend her!
Gweerasinghe87
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Amy is always a joy. She is organized, thorough and knowledgeable. Amy creates a stress free environment for buying/selling a home. I will always highly recommend Amy!
Stadanand
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was a pleasure to work with. Her expertise, suggestions and responsiveness made what coould have been a daunting experience go seamlessly. We sold our home very quickly and in the least disruptive manner we could have imagined.I highly recommend Amy and will certainly use her in the future with other home sales/purchases.
Steve J.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is the best! So easy to work with. As first-time buyers, she made the process simple and enjoyable. We couldnt have asked for a better experience. Thanks Amy!
Jeff W.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy came highly recommended by other homeowners in our neighborhood. We chose her for our listing because she was able to quickly understand our wants/needs and turn them into an action plan that was sound and well thought out. The result was more than we could have hoped for, with her supporting and staying closely connected throughout the prep, listing, and sale process. On many occasions, she went above and beyond to make sure our goals were meant. If you select Amy as your agent, you wont be disappointed.
Sawheels
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy was amazing!!! Amy is very knowledgeable about the real estate market. She is very professional along with being warm, kind and patient. We were looking for about a year...Amy was right there with us patiently supporting us to find the perfect home. She was very responsive, texting us immediately to any questions we had or anxiety about the process. BTW our house sold in 1 day. I really can?t say enough good things about Amy!!!
Rey R.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is a very professional real estate agent. She helped us buy our home 4 years ago and when we needed to sell our home we knew we would go back to her, She always contacted us in a timely matter. She did a fantastic job marketing our home and it was sold within 24 hours. She makes us feel like a part of her family ??
Camille R.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED When my parents needed to quickly move from their home of forty years into Assisted Living last fall, Amy Petrone was part guardian angel and part real estate broker! Amy was incredibly sympathetic to our situation and did not push us to list the house sooner than we were ready to. In fact, she told us that our timeline was her timeline - those words were what sold us on signing with Amy. The house needed to be thoroughly cleaned out and freshly painted. Every single contractor that Amy recommended was fantastic and fairly priced. Amy told us exactly what needed to be done to sell the house without going overboard. When it came time to list the house there was a bidding war and the house sold in days. I am telling everyone I know about how reliable, professional and responsive Amy is!
Soelkers
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy guided me through the process of finding the right house and getting the deal I needed to make it work! She had options and really worked to understand my needs. Thanks Amy!!
Kate B.
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy ensured the process of selling my condo was stress-free and smooth. She is very knowledgeable, personable, communicative, and detail-oriented. Within 24 hours of listing my condo, Amy had scheduled multiple showings and an open house which allowed me to accept an offer within 24 hours of listing my condo. From there, the process was simple.Overall, Amy exceeded my expectations in this process. I was on a tight timeline between selling my home/moving into my next residence and through selling my condo quickly, Amy helped ensure my move dates were met.I would highly recommend Amy to anyone selling or purchasing a residence. Her knowledge, communicative nature, and incredible team will ensure all critical parts of the process are covered proactively. Thank you, Amy!
Zuser20160610210211136
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy helped us buy a home in Rochester, NY. She was very knowledgeable about the entire process and about the real estate in the area. She was always responsive and accessible. We would definitely go to Amy as our real estate agent again should we ever need to buy or sell in the future.
Hollyjolottie44
Review for Member: Amy Petrone
ZillowVERIFIED Amy is a very professional real estate agent. She took the time to get to know us so she had an idea of what our expectations were. She always contacted us in a timely matter, in all aspects of the process. She did a fantastic job marketing our home, and it sold in only four days.
