Tammy Tinnerello

Sotheby's

8 Years of Experience

(28)

$36B

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

103

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$0.9M

Average Price Point

Service Areas
About
Recent Sales
Contact Information
Social Media
Specialities
Awards

Service Areas

Centerbrook, CT Essex, CT Groton, CT Mystic, CT Old Lyme, CT Waterford, CT

View All Service Areas

About Tammy Tinnerello

Since 2016, Tammy Tinnerello has set herself apart in Southeastern Connecticut as one of the region's top performing agents. Tammy possesses a rare combination of skills that give her an edge, such as her formidable negotiating skills and her ability to accurately read the market. Tammy's personality is also one of her greatest assets, as her honesty is valued by her clients. Her friendly and supportive relationships with fellow realtors allow her to maintain a strong network along the Shoreline and beyond. Tammy has in-depth knowledge of the market, school districts, and neighborhoods. Whether you are searching for a house to begin your next storyor selling one to write the next, every new beginning starts with a home. The energy and passion Tammy brings to real estate is also shared with her family and community. She lives in Old Lyme with her husband Joe, our four children Brooke, Salvatore, Bianca, and Lydia, and our West Highland terrier Winston. In her spare time, Tammy enjoys spending time with her family and friends, playing golf, pickleball, and cooking. Consult on Home Selling Tactics Oftentimes buyers don't visualize living in your home the way you do. I can make your home attractive to its ideal audience - which can help you get top dollar. Things like staging the home, making repairs or minor improvements, or even simply painting the walls can be the difference between a home resting on the market and one that's sold fast.

Specialties

Sellers
Residential Property

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Old Lyme, CT
2025
TOP AGENT
Essex, CT
2025
TOP AGENT
Waterford, CT

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 103

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.

Date

Address

Price

Represented

07/18/2025

9 Whisper Cove Road Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Sold For $3.4M

07/18/2025 Both

07/18/2025

1308 Durham Road Madison, CT 06443

Sold For $1.3M

07/18/2025 Seller

07/08/2025

220 Bushy Hill Road Deep River, CT 06417

Sold For $726.5K

07/08/2025 Buyer

06/20/2025

20 Otter Cove Drive Old Saybrook, CT 06475

Sold For $1.5M

06/20/2025 Buyer

Tammy Tinnerello's Reviews & Ratings

28 Reviews

(4.9/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Knowledgeable
Professional
Communicative
Responsive
Excellent negotiator
Outstanding
Trustworthy
Attentive
Hard working
Great for new buyers

Willa Kammerer

Review for Member: Willa Kammerer

July 1, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I had a truly exceptional experience working with Tammy to sell my home in WaterfordaEUR"especially during what turned out to be a challenging moment in the market. I met with three other realtors before choosing Tammy, and I never once second-guessed my decision. From start to finish, she made me feel supported, informed, and genuinely cared for. Tammy consistently went above and beyondaEUR"bringing fresh flowers for showings, adding thoughtful touches for the open house, and always showing up with warmth and professionalism. Shes not only personable and easy to work with, but also sharp, strategic, and deeply knowledgeable about the local market. I wholeheartedly recommend Tammy to anyone looking for a realtor they can truly trust, and I would gladly work with her again on either the buying or selling side of a future transaction. Thank you, Tammy!

Sjgeiger9

Review for Member: Sjgeiger9

June 8, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Tammy did an excellent job selling our house. Any issues that arose she was quick to respond and help provide solutions. Tammy delivered everything she promised. Hands-down, we would use her again and highly recommend her.

Dave2333

Review for Member: Dave2333

January 9, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Tammy was great to work with. She helped us with selling our home and buying our new home. She is very knowledgeable about the local area. She offered guidance when we needed it and helped us get through the process. She was always responsive. She was definitely looking out for our best interest. She was always pleasant to be around, and she treated everyone else with respect as well. We are super thankful that we found her through a friends recommendation!

Rich Shriver

Review for Member: Rich Shriver

June 5, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Tammy and her team were proactive, creative and professional. I enjoyed every phone conversation or in person meeting with her or her team, even if there were concerns to discuss. She handled the entire transaction from start to finish as someone who loves the real estate business and understands the needs of buyers and sellers.