Susan Muscarella

Property Sisters of Chautauqua

13 Years of Experience

(4)

$4M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$171.8K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Ashville, NY Celoron, NY Clymer, NY Frewsburg, NY Jamestown, NY Lakewood, NY Orchard Park, NY Panama, NY Steamburg, NY

View All Service Areas

About Susan Muscarella

Hello! Welcome to Property Sisters of Chautauqua! We are a Full Service Real Estate Agency, we can list your home, we can show you any home listed for sale in Chautauqua County. Also offering complete Property Management for Condos, Homes and Multi-Families! We have over 10 years of combined Real Estate experience and can not wait to serve you in anyway we can! Contact us with any questions @ Susan 716-969-8689. Thank You! Susan Muscarella Licensed Real Estate Professional Property Sisters of Chautauqua Mobile: 716-969-8689 Email: [email protected]

Credentials

LICENSE

Real Estate - New York - # 10401251661

Designation

Licensed Realtor

Specialties

Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
Mobile Homes

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Jamestown, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Ashville, NY
2025
TOP AGENT
Lakewood, NY

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Susan Muscarella's Reviews & Ratings

4 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Excellent negotiator
Communicative
Responsive

Kyoungberg12

Review for Member: Susan Muscarella

October 6, 2017

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Susan was so helpful when we were putting our house on the market! She answered all of our questions immediately and always had our best interest in mind. She got our house SOLD by getting us plenty of showings and seeking out prospective lookers. Thank you to Susan the process of selling our home was an easy one and we are very happy it went so smoothly! We would recommend her to anyone in the area looking to buy or sell, as she also has shown us many homes and has often worked to get us to be the first to look when something we may like goes on the market! Thank you Susan!!

House H.

Review for Member: Susan Muscarella

October 20, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Her positive, go get em attitude really shined during the process of our house buying experience. She was ready to answer tax questions for and point us in the direction of anything else we needed to find out. She is a great negotiator and we got our dream home for exactly the price we wanted it for! We have bought multiple homes from her and will continue to do so if we buy more in the future! #satisfiedhomebuyer #susanmuscarellasgreat!

Shawn D.

Review for Member: Susan Muscarella

September 23, 2013

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Susan Muscarella was ready, willing, and able to show my husband and I any houses we wanted, PLUS the houses she found that fit our criteria. Her honesty and integrity astonished me (in a good way)! She was always looking out for our best interest and saved us money during the whole process whenever she could. She was able to answer all of our questions and when she didn't know something she QUICKLY found the answers for us. Susan really made us feel like we were all a part of a team throughout the whole buying experience. She had our best interest at heart and never once tried to up sell us or take advantage of us. We will DEFINITELY be buying our next home from her!

Wifeee

Review for Member: Susan Muscarella

August 11, 2013

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

THANK GOD for Susan Muscarella!!She was so knowledgeable, accommodating, and enthusiastic! She was completely willing to show us all of the houses we wanted to see and more! She had answers to all of our questions, and any concerns we had she put our minds at ease. She LISTENED to our wants, needs, and the criteria we had in mind for our dream house. She was extremely proactive (and successful!) when it came to the negotiation process too! Needless to say, we are now first time homeowners and are 150% satisfied with our home buying experience! I honestly never thought ANY realtor would be able to meet every single one of the must haves we had (especially in Jamestown, NY), but Susan Muscarella did it EFFORTLESSLY......and quickly!