Nick Mastrangelo

Coldwell Banker

39 Years of Experience

(55)

$22.2M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

182

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$392.1K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Ansonia, CT Bethany, CT Branford, CT Derby, CT East Haven, CT Fairfield, CT Hamden, CT Milford, CT New Haven, CT North Haven, CT Northford, CT Orange, CT Shelton, CT Stratford, CT Trumbull, CT Wallingford, CT West Haven, CT Woodbridge, CT

View All Service Areas

About Nick Mastrangelo

Bringing results that move my clients has been my number one priority since the start of my real estate career. For more than three decades, I've had the privilege of serving as a trusted advisor to hundreds of buyers, sellers, and investors across Connecticut, guiding them through residential, commercial, and investment transactions of every size and scope. As the Team Leader of the Regional Properties Team at Coldwell Banker Realty, I'm proud to lead a top-producing group of professionals recognized as the #1 Medium Team in Connecticut for closed transactions. In 2024, I was honored to be named the Top Agent in Connecticut with Coldwell Banker, a reflection of the trust my clients place in me and my commitment to delivering exceptional results. What sets me apart is a client-first approach built on service, strategy, and trust. My clients benefit from: - Unmatched marketing expertise that maximizes exposure and drives powerful results. - Expert negotiation skills that protect their best interests. - Clear, consistent communication that creates confidence at every stage of the process. This dedication has earned me the Five Star Professional Award for seven consecutive years--a recognition of the level of service I bring to every client relationship. Whether you're buying your first home, relocating, downsizing, or exploring investment opportunities, my role as a trusted advisor is to provide the guidance, market knowledge, and results that move you forward with confidence. Beyond real estate, I remain deeply connected to my community. Raised in Orange, where my wife and I chose to raise our family, I've served on the board of the Orange Chamber of Commerce, as a member of the Water Pollution Control Authority (WPCA), and I actively support various charities throughout the year.

OTHER LANGUAGES

English

Community Involvement

Member of Orange Chamber of Commerce, Water Pollution Control Authority and support various charities each year.

HOBBIES/INTEREST

Time with my family and traveling.

Specialties

Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
Commercial Property

Awards

2025
TOP 15 AGENT
Connecticut
2025
TOP AGENT
New Haven, CT
2025
TOP AGENT
Orange, CT

Other Awards

Five Star Professional, International President's Elite

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Nick Mastrangelo's Reviews & Ratings

55 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Knowledgeable
Professional
Communicative
Responsive
Outstanding
Trustworthy
Attentive
Sold Quickly
Excellent negotiator

Tammi Baker

Review for Member: Tammi Baker

October 19, 2025

Are you looking for a broker who is at the top of his game If so Nick is your man He is very thorough and responsive He is a plethora of information and he saved us a lot of time and potential frustration We are truly grateful for his services and the timethoughtfulness that he exhibited throughout I cant speak highly enough of him Thank you so much Nick

Nate Baker

Review for Member: Nate Baker

October 18, 2025

The probate process to sell our moms house was quite confusing Being that neither my sister nor I ever dealt with this before we were completely in the dark Nick with his 30 years of experience was the shining light that guided us through that process He was completely attentive informative and responsive During some uncertain times Nick never wavered and was always reassuring His fearlessness and confidence were incredible to witness If you want a true professional who makes his clients needs a priority Nick is the man to hire We are incredibly grateful for Nick and his above and beyond the call of duty philosophy

Dick Contino

Review for Member: Dick Contino

October 3, 2025

Outstanding serviceassistance in our purchase of a waterfront home in Milford Nick Mastrangelo negotiating insights were the reason we had our bid accepted amid competition And Cindy Sloan who worked with Nick helped us stay on top of the many key details involved Highly recommend folks

Ed Rawls

Review for Member: Ed Rawls

September 26, 2025

We could have never overcome all the challenges we faced in selling our home There were things found in the inspection legal challenges and the obstacle of selling our home although we still have an eighteen year lease on our solar system Nick navigated us through it all and kept the buyer interested He is patient answers all your questions lets you make decisions after hearing all the ramifications and I believe he has super powers He and his assistant Cindy make an unstoppable team

Joyce Marzano

Review for Member: Joyce Marzano

July 4, 2025

We had a truly exceptional experience working with Nick as our real estate agent From start to finish he was incredibly helpful consistently kept us informed making the entire process feel seamless Nick was always just a phone call away ready with clear advice and genuine support Nicks assistant Cindy was equally helpful and responsive Together they made a fantastic team Highly recommend