Awarded FastExpert.com 2026 Five Star Agent - 2026 Florida Top 15 Agent - 2026 Bradenton Top Agent - 2026 Anna Maria Island Top Agent - 2026 Palmetto Top Agent. Nathan's customers praise his work ethic, professionalism, attention to detail, depth of expertise and dependability. Nathan is ranked among the Top 1.5% Individuals by Sales Volume Nationally and was voted by his past customers the 'Five Star Professional' Real Estate Agent Award from 2021 - 2026 for his professional excellence and superior customer service. As an agent who is an expert in this local area, combined with being trained as a Master Certified Negotiation Expert, Certified Listing Professional, Home Staging Expert, Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist, Certified Waterfront Specialist and Senior Real Estate Specialist, Nathan brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise about buying and selling real estate. Nathan began his real estate career by door-knocking on over 4,000 residential homes in the local area to introduce his real estate services. He then achieved the honor of being awarded the 2015 Keller Williams On The Water - Bradenton 'Rookie Of The Year' due to his outstanding sales performance and then went on to be awarded the 'Sales Associate Of The Year' in 2017. Nathan also owned and operated his own real estate brokerage for 3 years prior to moving his real estate services to Premier Sotheby's International Realty. With a background as a licensed financial service representative and real estate investor, Nathan understands that buying or selling a home is one of the biggest investment decisions you will ever make and is eager to work with you to meet your goals. Nathan prides himself on taking a pro-active approach towards making the real estate buying and selling experience as stress-free as possible from the initial meeting to the day of closing.
OTHER LANGUAGES
English
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Family Time, Sports, Golf, Exercising
FAMILY
Married since 8/8/08
Read More About Nathan
Credentials
LICENSE
Real Estate - Florida - # BK3307084
Designation
Master Certified Negotiation Expert(R), Home Staging Expert(R), Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (R), Senior Real Estate Specialist(R)
Specialties
Buyers
Sellers
Residential Property
Relocation, Home Staging Expert, Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist, Seniors Real Estate Specialist
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Bradenton, FL
2026
TOP AGENT
Palmetto, FL
2026
TOP AGENT
Anna Maria, FL
Other Awards
Nationally Ranked among the Top 1.5% Individuals by Sales Volume, Premier Sotheby's International Realty Top 25 Agent out of 1,400+ Agents * Five Star Professional Award Winner (2021-2026) * Keller Williams On The Water "Sales Associate Of The Year" (2017) and "Rookie Of The Year" (2015)
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Professional
Responsive
Knowledgeable
Communicative
Trustworthy
Outstanding
Hard working
Attentive
Sold Quickly
Available Remotely
Richard C.
Review for Member: Nathan Mathers
March 7, 2026
We've purchased several homes over our lifetime and we have never had a better experience. Nathan Mathers made it easy! He was more experienced, more knowledgeable and just plain friendlier than any other real estate agent we've ever dealt with. He was also so responsive, he always responded to our calls and followed up on everything we talked about. We highly recommend Nathan.
Ruthmurphy05
Review for Member: Nathan Mathers
December 23, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
Nathan was absolutely outstanding in all areas. He kept me up to date on all aspects of selling my home. He attended all showings personally. He had very good contacts for repairs needed based on inspection. He showcased my home in the local paper to attract more interest.
Ruth M.
Review for Member: Nathan Mathers
December 23, 2025
Nathan was absolutely outstanding in all areas. He kept me up to date on all aspects of selling my home. He attended all showings personally. He had very good contacts for repairs needed based on inspection. He showcased my home in the local paper to attract more interest.
William T.
Review for Member: Nathan Mathers
December 22, 2025
Nathan was a great communicator. Kept us informed daily, sometimes multiple times per day. We had a lot of respect for the knowledge he brought about the area. Very mild mannered, not pushy at all and respected our input in the entire process. We will buy again and we will hire Nathan in the future 100%. Canadians needing help this is the guy!
Gerald D.
Review for Member: Nathan Mathers
November 19, 2025
First one to reply when we were looking for a realtor Very high professional work ethics Excellent communication Excellent knowledge of his market Always realistic which is much appreciated