Natalie Clayton

Maywright Property Co.

9 Years of Experience

(33)

$20M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

113

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$382.5K

Average Price Point

Service Areas
About
Recent Sales
Contact Information
Social Media
Specialities
Awards

Service Areas

Indianapolis, IN

View All Service Areas

About Natalie Clayton

Natalie Clayton Top 1% Indianapolis broker Highlight: In 2020, Natalie achieved more than $20 million in sales and led The Clayton Team of six other agents who achieved $60 million in sales. Visit my website. Natalie Clayton is a founder and broker of Maywright Property Co., a fully-woman owned real estate brokerage serving clients and neighborhoods in central Indiana. As one of the top-ranked agents in Indianapolis, with over $20M in sales in 2020 and having led a team of agents that topped $60M in the same year, she brings to her work expertise, compassion and a commitment to empowering her clients and brokers every step of the way. In addition to her work at Maywright, Natalie owns 10+ real estate investments that range from single-family, multi-family and short-term rental. She believes in small business and is an investor in Milktooth, a nationally recognized restaurant in the Fletcher Place neighborhood. With more than 1,500 hours of service, Natalie founded Bourbon Women Indy, serves as vice president of the board at the Athenaeum Foundation, is president of the Community Heights Neighborhood Association, and is a member of Impact 100. In 2016, Natalie and her husband also launched a scholarship program for students who have shown a commitment to community and public service. Natalie is an Indianapolis native, a graduate of IUPUI, and has dedicated her career to knowing and serving this city and its people. Prior to entering real estate in 2017, Natalie spent a decade working in government and nonprofits, including serving as deputy director of the Greater Indianapolis Progress Committee under Mayor Ballard where she worked on projects like Eskenazi Hospital, Bank on Indy and the Charles L. Whistler Award. She has also held roles at the National Future Farmers of America and the Indiana State Museum. Since launching her real estate career, Natalie has been recognized as Rookie of the Year, an alumna of MIBOR's Real Estate Academy of Leadership (Class of 2018-2019), and the Bud Tucker Scholarship recipient. Natalie and her husband, Indiana State Representative Blake Johnson, reside in Indianapolis with their two dogs, Jack and Jamison.

Specialties

Sellers
Residential Property

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Indianapolis, IN

View All Awards

Recent Sales

Showing 4 out of 106

We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:

1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.

Date

Address

Price

Represented

05/27/2025

14447 Bishop Birch Pl Carmel, IN 46032

Sold For $665.7K

05/27/2025 Buyer

05/10/2025

3892 Morrison Rd Nashville, IN 47448

Sold For $340K

05/10/2025 Seller

04/30/2025

319 E 16th St UNIT 205 Indianapolis, IN 46202

Sold For $399.9K

04/30/2025 Seller

04/04/2025

2021 Carrollton Ave Indianapolis, IN 46202

Sold For $795K

04/04/2025 Seller

Natalie Clayton's Reviews & Ratings

33 Reviews

(4.9/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Communicative
Responsive
Professional
Knowledgeable
Outstanding
Attentive
Great for new buyers
Trustworthy
Available Remotely
Excellent negotiator

Waaron77062

Review for Member: Waaron77062

March 5, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Natalie was the BEST. Clear prompt communication. Easy to work with. Natalie was a great advocate. She helped us sell our near east side/Springdale home that had been on the market for months prior to switching realtors. Highly recommended!

Lauren Kenny

Review for Member: Lauren Kenny

January 5, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

As first-time homebuyers, we couldnt have asked for a better realtor than Natalie! From our first conversation, she supported us every step of the way. When we found a house we loved, she immediately jumped in to help us put in an offer the same day we toured it. She is calm, patient, and always took the time to answer our questions. We are so grateful for her guidance and couldnt have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend Natalie to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, responsive, and caring realtor!

Elias Khalil

Review for Member: Elias Khalil

December 17, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

It was great working with Natalie and her team on the sale of our house. Super responsive, kind and pragmatic. Her team is super efficient, very precise and works in a synchronized manneraEUR| Natalie delivered on expectations and more. We will work with her again.

Zuser20160801185406969

Review for Member: Zuser20160801185406969

October 29, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I found the house of my dreams, despite it looking nothing like my original search parameters and Natalie leveraged her understanding of real estate process, her negotiation skills, and her relationships to ensure I secured the house of my dreams. Now, several years later, she continues to be a resource aEUR" connecting me to the partners that make living in a century + year old home doable. I am so grateful for her as an advocate and friend.

Steven Friedmeyer

Review for Member: Steven Friedmeyer

September 25, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I was informed, after being approved for a rental property and providing the proper documentation for reasonable accommodation for my service animal, that there was a breed restriction for my service animal. I informed the owner, Natalie Clayton, of my rights under the FHA and that I would be filing a complaint with HUD. She then accused me of being aEURoecombativeaEUR?. After she spoke to an attorney, I was informed of an additional $350.00 "cleaning fee" in addition to the security deposit and a $300.00 administrative fee (also not listed on Zillow). I was then sent an incomplete lease without any Rent Amount, Term of Lease nor move-in date mentioned in the document. When I questioned this, I was told that I would need to fill in the appropriate information. The lease I was presented with was a Template not an actual legal and binding Lease Document. I believe the delay in obtaining the lease and the additional non listed fees were retaliation for my request for a reasonable accommodation due to my documented physical impairment. I have all communications between Natalie and myself preserved.