Service Areas
Bushkill, PADingmans Ferry, PAEast Stroudsburg, PAGreeley, PAGreentown, PAHamlin, PAHawley, PAHonesdale, PALackawaxen, PALake Ariel, PAMatamoras, PAMilford, PAMillrift, PAMount Pocono, PAShohola, PATafton, PATamiment, PA
View All Service Areas
About Lisa McAteer
Lisa McAteer is the #1 real estate agent in Pike County, Pennsylvania and the Team Leader and Co-Founder of McAteer & Will Estates | Keller Williams Real Estate. She is an award-winning, top-producing real estate professional recognized for her leadership, consistency, and market dominance in Pike County. Lisa's business is intentionally focused in Pike County, where her deep understanding of local market trends, pricing strategy, and buyer behavior allows her to position homes effectively and protect client interests in all market conditions. Lisa is known for strategic pricing, strong negotiation, transparent communication, and a disciplined, data-driven approach that helps buyers and sellers make confident, informed decisions while minimizing risk and maximizing results. As Team Leader, she oversees performance standards and client experience to ensure professionalism and consistency across every transaction. Her experience includes primary residences, second homes, lakefront properties, luxury homes, and rural estates. Lisa McAteer has received regional recognition from Keller Williams Realty and local business organizations for production, leadership, and community impact, and has been featured in regional media for her role as a local real estate authority. Buyers and sellers consistently choose Lisa McAteer as the most trusted and respected real estate agent in Pike County, Pennsylvania.
OTHER LANGUAGES
English
Community Involvement
Our team is deeply committed to strengthening the community we serve. Over the years, we've built a reputation not just as real estate leaders, but as community leaders, creating events that bring people together and enhance the quality of life across Pike County. Our efforts have been recognized by both the Pennsylvania Senate and the Pike County Chamber of Commerce for our meaningful community contributions. The Senate of Pennsylvania formally commended McAteer & Will Estates for: o Leadership o Service to the community o Commitment to excellence o Positive impact on Pike County residents We have also been honored by the Pike County Chamber of Commerce with the Hometown Hero Award for our contributions and dedication.
Read More About Lisa
Credentials
LICENSE
Real Estate - Pennsylvania - # RS344103
Designation
Seniors Real Estate Specialist
Licensed Realtor
Seller Representative Specialist
Top Producer
Specialties
- Buyers
- Sellers
- Residential Property
Residential Home Sales, Buyers & Commercial
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Milford, PA
2026
TOP AGENT
Dingmans Ferry, PA
2026
TOP AGENT
Hawley, PA
Other Awards
Top Listings, Closed Volume & Sales
View All Awards
FAQ
Buying a home requires clarity, preparation, and strong guidance—especially in competitive markets like Pike County. My advice is to focus on long-term value rather than trying to time the market. Get pre-approved early, understand local inventory trends, and work with an agent who knows how to position offers strategically. In Pike County, understanding pricing, competition, and timing at a neighborhood level can make the difference between winning and losing the right home.
For sellers, pricing strategy and presentation are everything. Homes in Pike County sell best when they are priced based on real market data, professionally marketed, and positioned correctly from day one. Overpricing costs time and leverage. I focus on data-driven pricing, strong negotiation, and targeted marketing to ensure sellers maximize value while minimizing risk.
I’ve worked with a wide range of clients including first-time buyers, move-up buyers, investors, and luxury sellers. As the Team Leader of McAteer & Will Estates, I’ve overseen hundreds of transactions across Pike County and the surrounding region, helping clients navigate everything from primary residences to second homes, lakefront properties, and rural estates.
A recent transaction that stands out involved a family relocating into Pike County from out of state in a highly competitive market. Inventory was tight and timing was critical, but through strategic offer positioning and clear communication, we secured the right home while protecting the client’s interests. Situations like this highlight the importance of local market knowledge and experience.
I began my career in broadcast journalism, which taught me how to communicate clearly, work under pressure, and advocate effectively. That foundation naturally led me into real estate, where strong communication and leadership are essential. Today, as Team Leader of McAteer & Will Estates, I apply those skills to guide clients through complex decisions and deliver consistent results across Pike County.
My background includes professional training in communication, negotiation, and leadership, along with ongoing education through Keller Williams Realty focused on market analysis, pricing strategy, and consumer behavior. As Team Leader of McAteer & Will Estates, I continuously study Pike County market trends, contract strategy, and risk management to ensure my clients benefit from informed guidance, strong advocacy, and data-driven decision-making throughout every transaction.
Contact Information
Location
402 Broad StreetMilford, PA, 18337
Social Media
Available Listings View All
Active
$259,000
3bds | 1ba 960 Acres
181 Sunrise Dr Milford, PA 18337,USA
Active
$150,000
3bds | 1ba 1148 Acres
134 Lakeview Dr Dingmans Ferry, PA 18328,USA
Active
$499,000
3bds | 2ba 1681 Acres
502 Route 2001 Milford, PA 18337,USA
Active
$350,000
bds | 0ba Acres
739 Pa Milford, PA 18337,USA
View All ListingsTrusted Professionals
Trusted Pro
Lisa McAteer is a Trusted Pro with a network of verified professionals.
Susan Cawley
Real Estate Agent
Justin Bosak
Real Estate Agent Other
ZillowVERIFIED