NJ Real Estate Advisor | 20+ Years Experience | Ocean & Monmouth Counties | Estate, Divorce & Lifestyle Transitions I help homeowners and families throughout Ocean and Monmouth Counties navigate buying and selling real estate--often during important life transitions where experience, discretion, and clear communication matter most. I bring over 20 years of real estate experience and recently retired from a 27-year career in law enforcement, serving as a Captain with the Brick Township Police Department. That background shaped the way I work today: calm under pressure, detail-oriented, and deeply committed to serving people from all walks of life with professionalism and respect. My clients benefit from strong local knowledge, including neighborhoods, school systems, and market trends throughout Monmouth and Ocean Counties. I regularly assist with traditional home sales, estate properties, downsizing, second homes, and waterfront real estate, and I work closely with attorneys, financial advisors, and other professionals when coordination is needed. I'm proud to be part of Keller Williams Shore Properties and the Shore Property Group, a small, collaborative team of experienced professionals. While each of us works independently, our team approach ensures clients are always supported, informed, and never left wondering what's happening with their transaction. Over the years, I've been recognized as a top agent in my market, earning the NJAR Circle of Excellence Sales Award in 2008 and consecutively each year since 2013, and being named a Five Star Professional in New Jersey Magazine for outstanding customer service. As a lifelong Jersey Shore resident, I specialize in communities including Point Pleasant, Manasquan, Sea Girt, Spring Lake, Brielle, Bay Head, Belmar, Wall Township, Brick Township, Bayville, and Toms River. Whether you're a first-time buyer, selling a longtime family home, or navigating a more complex real estate situation, my goal is to make the process as smooth, informed, and stress-free as possible--every step of the way. ? Serving Ocean & Monmouth Counties, NJ
OTHER LANGUAGES
English
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Golf, Beach, spending time with family & friends.
FAMILY
Married w/two kids.
Read More About Keith
Specialties
Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
Commercial Property
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Brick, NJ
2026
TOP AGENT
Point Pleasant Beach, NJ
Other Awards
NJAR Circle of Excellence Sales Award; 2008, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020.
View All Awards
FAQ
1. What advice would you give a buyer trying to purchase a home?
Contact me first!! Make sure you work with a professional who knows what they are doing and the area they service. Also if obtaining a mortgage, get pre-qualified prior to looking.
2. What advice would you give a seller trying to sell their home?
Meet with a professional realtor first, like myself. I can go over in detail what needs to be done to get your home ready for the market.
3. What types of clients have you worked with?
All types, first time home buyers, investors, buyers from out of state, etc.
4. Describe a recent transaction you are fond of. How did it go?
I met a woman from Virginia who inquired about a property that she saw online. I responded to her inquiry quickly and set up an appointment to see that particular home. Once we met I was able to obtain her needs/wants and shortly thereafter found her the home she was looking for. In this market we quickly submitted a strong offer and after some negotiations, her offer was accepted. From there I assisted her with home inspections and getting ready to close. It was a very smooth transaction and was possible because of my relationship with the listing agent also.
5. How did you get started in Real Estate?
I have always had an interest in real estate, so in 2002 I took the real estate class, passed the state exam and the rest is history.
6. Do you have any special education or training that will benefit your clients?
Nothing special, but I would say to check out reviews of me on Zillow.com. I have strong communication skills, always keeping in touch with my clients and assisting them through the entire process.
Contact Information
Location
46 E Water StreetToms River, NJ, 08753
Social Media
Keith Reinhard's Reviews & Ratings
102 Reviews
(5/5)
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Responsive
Professional
Knowledgeable
Communicative
Trustworthy
Hard working
Outstanding
Great for new buyers
Attentive
Sold Quickly
Matt P.
Review for Member: Keith Reinhard
November 18, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
Very helpful in every way. He knew what we were looking and the price range we were looking for. He also handled more than his share of the back and forth with the seller. Also recommended local contacts for services we would need, AC guy plumber, electrician and more. And Keith got us to the finish line.
Jbrowne756
Review for Member: Keith Reinhard
October 14, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
Throughout the home selling process Keith was incredibly communicative. He promptly answered calls and emails keeping me informed about all developments. Keith was extremely dedicated and understood the need to sell my parents' house in a timely manner.
Bmassa215
Review for Member: Keith Reinhard
August 25, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
Keith is a highly skilled individual that is proficient in every aspect of real estate. I know this first hand because I'm a retired realtor myself. He represented me as a seller and then as a buyer. This man attended to my every need, question, as well as frustration. When I wanted to walk away he calmly enlightened my fears and patiently waited for me to see both transactions come to fruition. He allowed me to bother him while he was in London and even addressed my concerns from the plane. His attention and availability is something every realtor should strive for. I would recommend him over and over again. If anyone is thinking of buying or selling I urge you to do so with Keith. You will have a smooth and rewarding experience. I cant thank him enough!
Dwfid
Review for Member: Keith Reinhard
July 25, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
Choosing my friend Keith to help sell my Jackson home was the best decision. He provided me with facts and was upfront with his opinions. His leadership and encouragement helped me to make decisions that were right for me. Thinking back about some of our conversations, I laugh because he was spot on with how it all played out. He did a great job for me and will also for you.
Thomas F.
Review for Member: Keith Reinhard
July 24, 2025
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
ZillowVERIFIED
We cant say enough great things about working with Keith! From selling our previous home to finding and closing on our absolute dream home, he made the entire process feel seamless and stress-free. His professionalism, attention to detail, and constant communication gave us total confidence every step of the way. Keith treated us like family (literally!) and went above and beyond to make sure everything moved quickly and smoothly. Whether it was staging advice, negotiating, or just answering a late-night question, he was always there. Were so grateful for his expertise and support aEUR" we couldnt have done this without him! If you're looking to buy or sell, Keith is the one you want in your corner.