Cynthia Hostetler Top real estate agent in Middlebury

Cynthia Hostetler

Brightstar RES
23 Years of Experience
(6)
$0
Total Sales Last Year
23
Years of Experience
29
Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years
$222.2K
Average Price Point

    About Cynthia Hostetler

    Cynthia grew up in the LaGrange County area and graduated from Westview High School in 1979. Shortly after, she started a family when she married her husband, Brad, on April 11th, 1980. Together they have one daughter, Kara and granddaughter Olivia. Cynthia & her husband Brad reside in Shipshewana & enjoy the rural Northeast Indiana lifestyle. Cynthia started out as a hairdresser and went on to be a business owner for 12 years. In 2002, Cynthia decided to pursue a career in real estate & became a Realtor®. Since then, Cynthia has become a local expert in the LaGrange county market & has continued her real estate education becoming a Certified Residential Specialist, Quality Service Certified, Certified New Home Specialist, and an e-Pro Internet Professional. She has been with the same real estate company throughout her real estate career. Cynthia has received the Diamond Premier Service Award for her exceptional customer service awarded to her by her clients' high ratings. Cynthia also serves as a broker for Mike Thomas Associates in LaGrange in addition to helping her clients buy & sell real estate full time. Cynthia's daughter Kara joined her in 2017 and together they form The Hostetler Team. Kara graduated from Westview High School in 2003. She Graduated from Columbia College in 2012 with a Bachelor's in History and Graduated from Western Governor's University in 2017 with her Master's in Business Administration. Kara has one daughter named Olivia and two fur babies (a dog and a cat). Kara loves helping clients find their new homes!
    Read More About Cynthia

    Credentials

    LICENSE
    Real Estate - Indiana - # RB14030057
    Designation

    Real Estate Broker

    ePro

    REALTOR

    Specialties

    • Sellers

    Awards

    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Howe, IN

    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Lagrange, IN

    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Shipshewana, IN

    View All Awards

    Loading recent sales...

    Cynthia Hostetler's Reviews & Ratings

    6 Reviews
    (5/5)
    Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
    What clients say about this agent....
    • Responsive
    • Communicative
    • Great for new buyers
    • Outstanding

    Dj432361

    Review for Member: Dj432361
    June 11, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Working with Kara was wonderful. She made the whole process easy. Our home was only on the market for 20 days. Whole process was fast which is what we wanted. This is the 3rd time she has helped us with either selling or buying. We highly recommend.

    Zuser20151202154002295

    Review for Member: Zuser20151202154002295
    December 19, 2018
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    With this being out first home purchase we had no idea where to start. Kara and Cynthia went above and beyond to make sure my wife and I knew exactly what we were looking at from the time of the showing to the final paperwork. They were very helpful and knowledgeable with not only the process but doing what ls best for us as homeowners! Highly recommended by us!!!

    Jeffbowman96

    Review for Member: Jeffbowman96
    October 1, 2018
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    The team handled everything exceptionally well and got us from listing to closing with no hiccups. Issues with the inspection and appraisal were dealt with promptly. During the viewing phase, we were given feedback and communication was excellent. Highly recommend Cynthia and Kara.

    Pbontrager1

    Review for Member: Pbontrager1
    September 20, 2018
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Our experience was great, we highly recommend! The Hostetler Team was very knowledgeable of the area and helped us sell the property in no time. They are very friendly and are there to help at any time.

    John9656

    Review for Member: John9656
    August 14, 2017
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    I have worked with many real estate people on many properties for over 40 years . These ladies are a cut above them all .!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Contact Information

    Location

    55137 Indiana 13 #1 Middlebury, IN, 46540

    Social Media

    More Agents Near You