Carolyn Mayhew

Featured

Mayhew Realty Group

16 Years of Experience

(35)

$24M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

215

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

Service Areas

Blue Eye, MO Branson, MO Cape Fair, MO Chestnutridge, MO Eagle Rock, MO Forsyth, MO Galena, MO Golden, MO Highlandville, MO Hollister, MO Kimberling City, MO Kirbyville, MO Kissee Mills, MO Lampe, MO Point Lookout, MO Powersite, MO Reeds Spring, MO Ridgedale, MO Rockaway Beach, MO Shell Knob, MO Spokane, MO Walnut Shade, MO

View All Service Areas

About Carolyn Mayhew

You won't find me sitting in the office!! NOPE!!
I'm out selling homes!!! I'm "On the MOVE, so YOU can MOVE!!!"
So whether you are buying or selling, let me put my experience to work for you!
More Tools, More Advertising, More Systems!! Put my Team of Experts to work for YOU!!

Specialties

Buyers
Sellers
Residential Property

Buyer's Agent, Listing Agent, Relocation, Foreclosure

Awards

2026
TOP 25 AGENT
Missouri
2026
TOP AGENT
Branson, MO
2026
TOP AGENT
Shell Knob, MO

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Carolyn Mayhew's Reviews & Ratings

35 Reviews

(4.7/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Responsive
Communicative
Professional
Available Remotely
Knowledgeable
Outstanding
Attentive
Excellent negotiator
Great for new buyers
Hard working

Linda J.

Review for Member: Carolyn Mayhew

September 8, 2025

FastExpert

FastExpert Verified

Review Submitted: September 8, 2025

Agent Name: Carolyn Mayhew

Client Name: Linda J.

Transaction Type: sell

Property Address:

<Address Hidden> Reeds Spring, MO 65737

Introduction Made: January 18, 2025

Closed: Sep 2025

FastExpertVERIFIED

Very pleased with Carolyns service.

Dan P.

Review for Member: Carolyn Mayhew

August 16, 2025

FastExpert

FastExpert Verified

Review Submitted: August 16, 2025

Agent Name: Carolyn Mayhew

Client Name: Dan P.

Transaction Type: sell

Property Address:

<Address Hidden> Branson West, MO 65737

Introduction Made: February 28, 2023

Closed: Aug 2025

FastExpertVERIFIED

Carolyn sold a lot that we had owned in Stonebridge (Branson) with ease. We selected her on-line because of her responsiveness and previous accomplishments that we had read on sites like this from previous customers. She didn't disappoint us; great communications and follow-up. Best thing was the sale came in less than a couple months after listing with Carolyn. Our transaction was handled easily enough entirely as a remote transaction since we'd move out of state and didn't have the ability to physically be there. I would highly recommend Carolyn for your real estate needs.

Toni J.

Review for Member: Carolyn Mayhew

July 26, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I cant say enough about how wonderful Carolyn wasaEUR|we chose the right and absolute BEST realtor to work with, and have already recommended her to friends, should they decide to sell in the future. Carolyn went above and beyond in our selling experience, which had some challenges for us. She was pro-active, took care of everything and was very patient with us. She responded immediately with every text or phone call. We are so thankful to have chosen her to represent us. We met Carolyn very briefly years ago, and I knew right away she was a good person. When we decided to sell our home years later, I remembered her, so thats who I called. I'm so thankful I did.

User42930696

Review for Member: Carolyn Mayhew

June 18, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Carolyn and her team are very knowledgeable of the lake market. I have used the Mayhew team to sell 2 homes and purchasing a few lots and have had a good experience each time. They are very prompt with responses and provide hard data when making decisions making the home buying process seamless.

Peggy K.

Review for Member: Carolyn Mayhew

September 25, 2024

FastExpert

FastExpert Verified

Review Submitted: September 25, 2024

Client Name: Peggy K.

Transaction Type: sell

Property Address:

<Address Hidden> Shell Knob, MO 65747

Introduction Made: June 01, 2024

Closed: Sep 2024

FastExpertVERIFIED

I'm happy with the results.

Contact Information

Location

2101 State Hwy 248Branson, MO, 65616