Carolyn Fahey

Fahey Realtors

22 Years of Experience

(32)

$35M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$1.3M

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Bedminster, NJ Bernardsville, NJ Chester, NJ Far Hills, NJ Gladstone, NJ Mendham, NJ Morristown, NJ Peapack, NJ Pluckemin, NJ Pottersville, NJ

View All Service Areas

About Carolyn Fahey

As a Broker-Owner of Fahey Realtors, Carolyn focuses on delivering customized solutions and exceptional service to clients for all of their real estate needs. With over 22 years in the business, Carolyn has completed over 600 transactions and has developed an expertise in listing and selling homes, land development, high-end new construction, and a variety of re-sales in the Somerset Hills. Carolyn also specializes in working with buyers to find their perfect home. Buyers are impressed with her knowledge and dedication to unparalleled client service. In addition to her expertise as a top salesperson, Carolyn, a Bernardsville native, can offer first-hand experience with the schools, community and people in the area. As the third daughter of Angela and Richard Fahey, the company's founders, Carolyn has been exposed to the Real Estate industry throughout her life. As the owner, she takes pride in continuing their tradition of integrity and "treating clients like family" to deliver the ultimate client experience. Carolyn is a graduate of Bernards High School and Colgate University Magna Cum Laude. She holds her NJ and NY Real Estate Licenses, her NJ Broker's License as well as the Series 7 and Series 63 Registrations in Securities. Prior to joining the family business, Carolyn spent five years with Merrill Lynch & Co. in New York City where she served as Vice President in the Private Wealth Marketing Division.In her spare time, she serves as Board President of PS108, a non-profit yoga studio in Bedminster and volunteer coach for "Girls on the Run" (a self-esteem/running program for young girls). Carolyn enjoys golf at Roxiticus Golf Club, tennis, yoga, spending time with family and interior design.

Community Involvement

Board President of PS108, a non-profit yoga studio in Bedminster and volunteer coach for "Girls on the Run" (a self-esteem/running program for young girls).

HOBBIES/INTEREST

Carolyn enjoys golf at Roxiticus Golf Club, tennis, yoga, spending time with family and interior design.

FAMILY

Married with one child

Specialties

Buyers
Sellers
Residential Property

Awards

2025
TOP AGENT
Bernardsville, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Mendham, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Bedminster, NJ

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Carolyn Fahey's Reviews & Ratings

32 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Knowledgeable
Professional
Responsive
Hard working
Communicative
Outstanding
Attentive
Trustworthy

Matthew F.

Review for Member: Carolyn Fahey

July 4, 2022

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Carolyn and Steinar were amazingly supportive as we bought our first house in an incredibly difficult market. They helped by educating us, sharing listings based on our preferences and feedback, and touring homes with us even on very short notice. They also were instrumental in a clean closing (despite the house throwing us a last-minute curveball) and Steinar even helped us open our new pool. If youre looking for a local expert, you cannot go wrong with the Fahey team. They treated us like we were family and we are thrilled with the outcome!

Rmshaw N.

Review for Member: Carolyn Fahey

April 30, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

We met Steinar when we went to see a house that he was showing for Fahey Realtors. While the house wasn't right for us, we were impressed with Steinar's knowledge, attitude, and customer focused approach and we decided to work with him in our search. He ended up showing us a number of houses including the one we ultimately purchased. He was extremely helpful in guiding us through that process. We would definitely work with him again and recommend him to others.

Madora K.

Review for Member: Carolyn Fahey

January 29, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Steinar was a joy to work with, from start to finish. He was professional, warm and friendly, and reliable. Didn't push us, but was readily available to answer all of our questions. We felt like he was working both for and with us.And, on the day of the closing, at the final walk through, he was amazing. Totally focused on every detail of our soon to be new house. Checking that everything was in order, not just giving a cursory look. We recommend him 100%.

William O.

Review for Member: Carolyn Fahey

January 19, 2021

FastExpert

FastExpert Verified

Review Submitted: January 19, 2021

Client Name: William O.

Transaction Type: sell

Property Address:

<Address Hidden> Bernardsville, NJ 07924

Introduction Made: May 27, 2020

Closed: Jan 2021

FastExpertVERIFIED

Carolyn, Ashley and their entire expert team were superb in advising and representing us in the sale of our home of 26 years...we recommend them all without qualification

Zuser20150822100058436

Review for Member: Carolyn Fahey

October 1, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Kelly was an amazingly thoughtful and knowledgeable realtor. Most importantly she took the time to listen and showed us houses that aligned with our preferences, budget etc. She made a stressful process extremely smooth and was a tireless advocate on our behalf throughout. Could not recommend her more!